Need help ranking

[IngeTheHammerStrom]

For my upcoming draft I will need to select my 2nd keeper and am planning on who to target.

Settings for Goalies in our league are Wins, SV% and GAA

The top options (in the order I am ranking are)

Talbot
Georgiev
Husso
Thompson
Samsonov
Binnington
Petersen

Do you agree with this order?

[Caps Crazy]

I would move up Samsonov and move down Talbot a bit.

Here is how I would rank them.

Georgiev
Husso
Samsonov
Talbot
Binnington
Thompson
Petersen

[stevegamer]

If you're looking for a player you are required to keep, I'd change the order some.

I move Samsonov up, because if he takes the clearly available starter job in Toronto, you want him. I'm far less convinced that Husso & especially Thompson go into next season as the unquestioned starter.


Talbot - I think he's a safe bet to be at least a 1A and not impode. However, he isn't along-term keeper option, really.
Georgiev - If he runs with the starting job, you're golden. Francouz will get starts and will play well, he's the best backup on any of these teams.
Samsonov - Murray is incredibly overrated. Toronto should've gone in another direction, but he's got the contract, and his name on a Cup.
Husso - Time to see if he's more ready than Ned is to be the guy one a solid team.
Binnington - I feel the ratios may be shaky, but the volume will be there.
Petersen - LA's goalie of the future, which could be now, if he's ready for it. He wasn't last year.
Thompson - a 3 headed goalie competition for this year where the winner gets to then face the incumbent starter who is out for a year seems like a poor option for guy in a keeper spot.

[chuckcouples]

Thompson
Talbot
Husso
Samsonov
Petersen
Binnington
Georgiev

That's how I would rank them.