McCann / Jarry vs Batherson / Gibson

[CAN-AM Commish]

16 Team H2H Cats
G, A, Pts, Hits, Blocks, SOG, FOW, TOI
W, Svs, Sv% GAA

I would give Batherson and Gibson
I would receive Jarry and McCann

I like McCann but Batherson has more value.
I like Jarry over Gibson

Can I get some thoughts around this? Thanks

[havanablast21]

For me Batherson >> McCann
But Jarry >/= Gibson.

Because goalies are voodoo… give me the Batherson side because Jarry isn’t enough for me to downgrade Batherson to McCann.

I prefer what you have.

[Belexus75]

yeah Batherson...people are trying to buy him low all over, happened to me today. If healthy mark him for 75 over 82 and great multicat contribution overall

[stevegamer]

I strongly prefer Jarry & Batherson, so it depends on what you need.

Gibson has been a tandem/backup quality NHL goalie the last 3 years. I don't expect that to suddenly change. McCann is at least likely to not be a negative presence on your team.

[CAN-AM Commish]

I cant have both Jarry and Batherson. I would be moving Batherson and Gibson. I was trying to get Jarry

[stevegamer]

I cant have both Jarry and Batherson. I would be moving Batherson and Gibson. I was trying to get Jarry

Sorry if I was unclear and that was directed at me. If you need a golaie, Jarry is the side you want. If you need a skater, Batherson is the side you want. It all depends on what you need.

[Bubba55]

Sorry if I was unclear and that was directed at me. If you need a golaie, Jarry is the side you want. If you need a skater, Batherson is the side you want. It all depends on what you need.

Jarry is an improvement on Gibson....maybe, then again, maybe not, and if he is an improvement, by how much? Batherson is a much better own than McCann IMO, a much better own. Personally, given my love of goalies I'd roll with Gibson and Batherson but it all depends on whether you think Jarry is clearly the better own than Gibson. If you do, fine. If your not so sure you stand pat.

[CAN-AM Commish]

Thanks we are still working on the details....
I like Jarry
I like Gibson, but Jarry better
I like Batherson
I like McCann but Batherson better

We are working on adding a 3rd player to each side.
We shall see how it goes.