Bennett (4.425) + 7th overall vs E. Kane (5.125) + 20th overall

[tobias]

Full keeper league, who do you prefer? Thinking more from an offensive standpoint (G,A, PPP, SOG).

Kane has the higher ceiling with McDavid, but is Kane's injury and behaviour history and potential future issues worth going from drafting someone like a Kemell for the farm to drafting someone like a Firkus to do so?

[thunderfist138]

What’s your cap situation like? Is this a trade proposal, if so which one do you own?

I like kane more than bennet, more so if you count pims. The safer bet is probably bennet and the better pick. But kane is a shots beast, and should be getting the puck fed to him constantly from McDavid, plus a net front presence on the PP. neither is a bad keeper, but the risk I think will be worth the reward of kane. And this is assuming a regression, I think he still beats Bennet on points and shots. Plus he’s under contract for an extra year.

My gut says kane.

[Sawch]

I’m taking Kane pretty easily here.

[Bubba55]

Kane