Svech or M Tkachuk - Keeper value + ROS

[Robbie35]

Considering 'something' with another owner that has Matthew Tkachuk and Weeger, he only has one goalie (Gibson and streams the other).

My keepers for this year were Kucherov, Eichel, Svechnikov and Shesterkin. I landed Fox first overall this year and he's making me think about my strategy a little on the keeper front.

In our points setup, Svech vs. Tkachuk play out as follows:

Last 30 Days: Svech 49.25pts vs. Tkachuk 60.20
Season: Svech 170.15ts vs. Tkachuk 195.55pts
Last Season: Svech 242.65pts vs. Tkachuk 245.25pts

If I plan to swap in Fox as a keeper (out performed both of the above based on the same stats), does Tkachuk offer a bit more ROS outlook? Whichever the other owner has, he'll likely keep.

Other option is dangling Campbell and then I stream a #2 (Francouz, Kahkonen, Oettinger are available) as Campbell+Shesty overlap A LOT with starts.

I'm hoping for a 2:1 or 3:2 deal, as I have Buch to activate followed by (hopefully) Palat, Wheeler and Eichel.

[stevegamer]

I'd be willing to move Svechnikov to get Tkachuk. If you can also get Weegar, then that helps you a lot as well. I'd be willing to deal Campbell & Svech & say, Barrie for Tkachuk/Weegar.

[Robbie35]

Thanks ... I know it's roster bias that I automatically feel like it's an over pay with both Svech + Campbell, but understand Barrie has ZERO value at the moment.

"If" I could jedi mind trick the owner, would Landeskog+Doughty be more enticing for that same package?

[LeafsFan1967]

Svech is over 2 years younger, let's see where he is when he's Tkachuk's age. I'd take Svech here, the guy has massive upside.

[iglooinhabitant]

I'd take Svech over Tkachuk quite easily. He's a much more talented individual player and is still just a baby. He's put up his numbers mostly without Aho as well so far!

[Robbie35]

For me it's also based on what I do for next year keeper wise, previously I kept Kuch, Eichel, Svech and Shesterkin ... but then I landed Fox this year.

If I can land a 1-year stud (or 2) that's outperforming Svech, that's where my head is at on moving him so I can keep Fox. All assuming Eichel's return is magical in Vegas.

The other package I considered (mentioned above) was Landeskog, Doughty, Fleury for Svech + Campbell. My goalies overlap so much I need a west coast goalie and I'm intrigued based on Fleury's currency on the trade front.

[Wonko]

I prefer M. Tkachuk, but it is close to a wash.

[tweetdrivr]

I prefer Svech by quite a bit.

[Avs31]

I prefer Svech. But like you said in a limited keeper with other great options tough to keep everyone. If it were me I would find a way to keep Svech. If it were me I prob keep him over Eichel based on his massive upside. never was a big fan of Eichel though but intrigued to see how he does in Vegas. Shesterkin might be the easier drop in a keep 4 depending what kind or goalies are available every year. Svech Eichel Kucherov Fox is tempting.