Theodore or Chabot

[Swarley]

Second league in signature, who do you prefer. Both would end up a keeper. I prefer Theo by a bit but the extra games Ottawa has left make me lean Chabot. Long term who is the better own? Will rep where I can

[2014olympicgold]

Chabot - 152gp, 13G, 76A, 92PIM, 394SOG, 186hits, 211blocks
Theodore - 160gp, 28G, 86A, 51PIM, 478SOG, 56hits, 154blocks

I like Theodore more, but Chabot will actually contribute to hits. Chabot will likely hit the higher points in 1 yr between the two because Chabot should be relied upon more. But Theodore is likely the safer bet.

Theodore is a 50-60pt dman. Chabot is a 45-70pt dman with hits.

[Bubba55]

Chabot - 152gp, 13G, 76A, 92PIM, 394SOG, 186hits, 211blocks
Theodore - 160gp, 28G, 86A, 51PIM, 478SOG, 56hits, 154blocks

Frozen Tools Rocks (:

I like Chabot here with your scoring format. There is every chance that Theodore is the better offensive producer. That said, the Sens have a good young team and the offense will improve and Chabot should benefit from that. So, pts and SOG goes to Theodore. I don't see this changing but I think there is a good chsnce that the numbers are closer than they are now.


The PIM, the Hits and the Blks go to Chabot. That I don't see changing. These guys are quite different players, Theodore is significantly more one dimensional than Chabot. If Chabot's offense improves as the Sens improve I think that makes Chabot the better own in your format.

Theodore is likely the safer bet, but IMO, it's very close and for the reasons I have touched on I'm liking Chabot here.

[Swarley]

Thanks for the replies, repped both of you. Just found out the Chabot owner isn’t interested though so I’ll just keep Theodore.

[zambronies]

I prefer Theodore