Hintz or Hertl?

[gogoayane]

Team in Sig 2

I posted this in the goalie forum earlier. Looking to trade one of Elvis or Smith and keep the other as my 3rd string. I have the following two offers in place and need to decide soon:

Smith for Hintz
or
Elvis for Hertl (Atkinson and Garland are also available)

I feel my team needs more goal scorer and shots. Hintz to be is a bit better than Hertl but Smith might be a better 3rd string goalie also.

Who would you go with?

(I could also trade both goalies out and pick up Francouz, Driedger, Allen, Lankinen, Raanta as my 3rd)

Will rep. Thanks!

[Daydream Nation]

I like Hintz over Hertl too. If Hintz puts it all together and stays healthy, he's a 70+ point player and point/game wouldn't surprise me.

[Feenom]

I like Hintz over Hertl too. If Hintz puts it all together and stays healthy, he's a 70+ point player and point/game wouldn't surprise me.

Could say the same about Hertl. Hintz does have better weapons to play with though...

[gogoayane]

I'm a bit torn as both are good players. Might lean on Hertl so I can keep Smith as my 3rd goalie instead of Elvis.

[GTX]

I would trade both and pickup Francouz. Andersen + Talbot + 3rd goalie (streaming) should be competitive team for goalies stats.
And you will boost the skater's numbers. There is a lot of uncertainty in Smith and Edmonton.

[Invictus]

I before E except after C

[Feenom]

I before E except after C

Is Y still a vowel?

[Invictus]

Is Y still a vowel?

When a word has no other vowels.. Yes

Luckily Hintz and Hertl don't have any Y's. Just G's and A's for some sweet sweet P's!

[rufio.85]

I'm voting Hintz here, especially since the price to acquire him is Mike Smith.
I'd rather keep Elvis who I think can put up some sneaky good numbers in Columbus.

[gogoayane]

Thanks everyone - I think I'll go with Hintz. I have Seguin who I can replace with Hintz. I think Smith will put up good numbers but really not sure about his health going forward.