I am in a keeper league that is simply 1 pt for goals/assists and 1.5 pts for a win and 2.o pts for shutout.
I am able to keep 12 players and 5 rookies at end of season.
My roster is as follows:
Pettersson, Stamkos, Connor, Guentzel, Verhaeghe, Hyman, Landeskog, Lindholm, Couturier, Batherson, Marchessault, Dahlin, Fox, Pietrangelo, Slavin
Goalies: Vasilevskiy, Shesterkin, Price and Bernier
Rookies: Raymond, Lundell, Byram, Boldy, Rathbone, Raty
Every week I must dress 9 forwards, 4 defenseman and 2 goalies

I have been offered the following:

Barzal, Theodore and Heinola


Byram, Batherson and Raty

I really don't want to trade Batherson, so have countered with Verhaeghe instead.

Would you make either of these trades.