Keeper Decisions

[2014olympicgold]

I got 2 teams where I have a couple of questions when it comes to keepers.

Lets start with the weirder one
16 team league. 0.5PPR
QB, 2RB, 2WR, TE, K, DEF, RB/WR/TE, 6BN
I have a question between 5 guys for "Up to 4" keepers. I must keep 1, but if I keep more I forfeit picks the more I keep (I keep 4, I use my first 4 picks if that makes sense).

Barkley, CEH, McLaurin are the real for sures, but then I question between Dobbins and Prescott. QBs are huge in this league, and I have 2 5th round (1st after keepers).


Team #2:
10 team, PPR, Keep 4 or 5 if you forfeit your 1st round pick
QB, 3WR, 2RB, TE, FLX, K, DEF, 8BN
Jefferson, Dobbins, McLaurin, Kittle...and no one else.

This is more how confident are you in Dobbins. There's a few teams willing to part with some top guys and I would be acquiring them to replace Dobbins. Here's the top guys:
Jonathan Taylor, Eckeler, Carson, Allen Robinson, Keenan Allen, Aaron Jones, Ridley, Jacobs, CEH, Woods, Derrick Henry, Kamara

[Blues_fan1000]

team 1. i'd keep who you have, including dak. everything seems poised for an improvement over last year, if that's even possible

team 2. depends on what you're giving up to replace dobbins. there are a ton of top tier players on your acquiring list that would interest me. of your list, i think i'd be most interested in JTaylor. Henry is a beast, but not sure how much longer he can carry the ball 10000000 times a season. I like kamara too, especially with PPR, but with his qb situation, i think the saints might be sliding into a terrible team so not sure his long term value. Ridley, maybe, but it's hard to swap a WR for a RB when the gap between top tier and mid tier rbs are so bad and WR is much closer.

Dobbins could blow up, but he still has a very mobile qb that's going no where so he'll loose some tds, plus really not sure how much the ravens use edwards again, he got a decenet amount of touches last year too

[2014olympicgold]

10 team, Keep 4 (or 5, forfeit 1st round pick) PPR
QB, 3WR, 2RB, TE, FLX, K, DEF, 8BN
My keepers are Kittle, McLaurin, Dobbins, Jefferson. There's no one else worth keeping outside of them.

Do I swap My Kittle and Jefferson for his Tyreek Hill and Mark Andrews? I was pushing for Kittle/McLaurin but he said no. He's also offered up Metcalf as well instead of Hill. I've asked for Metcalf/Andrews for Kittle/McLaurin but he was hesitant, but ended up saying no.

[2014olympicgold]

So I also have a potential of another trade.

So in previous convos with another GM, he wants a WR for Jonathan Taylor. So I asked him what his thoughts on Hill for Taylor/DJ Moore.

So would it make sense for this to happen:
Jefferson/Kittle for Andrews/Taylor/Moore. Then I would still likely keep 4 in Taylor, Moore, McLaurin, Dobbins.

I have asked the original GM for a McLaurin/Kittle/10th for Hill/Andrews/Last round to just get that done to keep Jefferson on my team.