Kyle Connor vs Matthew Tkachuk vs Brady Tkachuk (non-banger, REP)

[DS7]

Who would you keep? Seems like Brady hasn't truly broken out yet, Matt and Kyle both had slump years relative to the years before. While Matt has disappointed, Kyle went Ice
cold when Ehlers went down.

G, A, +/-, PIMs, PPP, shots.

I'm leaning Matthew Tkachuk simply because of his dual eligiblity (LW/RW) am i that far off?

[bbfl1987]

Connor for me. He should be a point per game guy for a long time. Matt may get there a couple times, but I see him settling in as more of a 70-75 guy. In a non banger league I see Brady slightly lower than his brother.

[Smurf54]

In general, we need more detail on your league setup (as it doesn't look like this is the league in your sig). However, in a vacuum, the inclusion of PIM and SOG makes me lean towards Brady. PIM guys are hard to find in general, but having one that can score and lead the league in SOG at the same time is super rare. Although his offence trails Connor and his brother, I think Brady will become a pretty regular 60-70pt guy. And his +/- will improve as Ottawa does, which I believe will happen sooner than later. So while he may rail in G/A/PPP, I don't think the gap will be anywhere near as big as t is now. And the PIM/SOG will easily make up for it.

[2014olympicgold]

I would say depending on the playoff performance of Connor, this is the ranking:

Connor/Brady
Matthew

Connor is a VERY good player, but he went cold when Ehlers was hurt. The twos chemistry is solid. Matthew Tkachuk is only the 3rd option because the other two are as good as they are. I wouldn't be surprised if any became the best player out of the bunch. I would personally go with Connor, but B.Tkachuk depending on your roster could make more sense.

[Turbo_Supremo]

I believe the fact that PIMS and Shots are included, I would go Brady all day. Connor will likely out-point Brady, but Brady will easily surpass Connor for PIMS and Shots.
Brady gets the edge over Matt because of the system he is in. Ottawa is letting the young guys skate, where Calgary is trying to implement Suters defensive system, and unless that changes, Matt won't be producing as much.

My ranking;
Brady
Connor
Matt

Cheers!

[Belexus75]

I would say depending on the playoff performance of Connor, this is the ranking:

Connor/Brady
Matthew

Connor is a VERY good player, but he went cold when Ehlers was hurt. The twos chemistry is solid. Matthew Tkachuk is only the 3rd option because the other two are as good as they are. I wouldn't be surprised if any became the best player out of the bunch. I would personally go with Connor, but B.Tkachuk depending on your roster could make more sense.

this

[senryu]

Brady
Connor, slightly behind
Matthew, good but clearly 3rd in this scenario.

[DS7]

Thank you everyone! Repped!

I forgot to mention that shots and Pims are weighted less than goals and assists in my league (0.1 pts/shot, 0.2/PIM) so I'm now leaning a bit to Connor in this regard.

[skinnypete88]

Thank you everyone! Repped!

I forgot to mention that shots and Pims are weighted less than goals and assists in my league (0.1 pts/shot, 0.2/PIM) so I'm now leaning a bit to Connor in this regard.

Even then I would agree with the consensus that depending on who else is on your roster, Brady might have more value because he fills more holes for your team overall.

[Feenom]

I would say depending on the playoff performance of Connor, this is the ranking:

Connor/Brady
Matthew

Connor is a VERY good player, but he went cold when Ehlers was hurt. The twos chemistry is solid. Matthew Tkachuk is only the 3rd option because the other two are as good as they are. I wouldn't be surprised if any became the best player out of the bunch. I would personally go with Connor, but B.Tkachuk depending on your roster could make more sense.

agreed