Keep One - Andersen, Lehner, or Jarry

[alastairzander]

Cats are wins, save %, and GAA. It's gotta be between Jarry and Lehner right?

[2014olympicgold]

A lot changes with Seattle and where goalies go, but the order for me is:

Lehner
Andersen/Jarry

Andersen is over Jarry depending where Andersen goes, Jarry is right now over Andersen if you need to make the choice today.

[hockeyrobot]

A lot changes with Seattle and where goalies go, but the order for me is:

Lehner
Andersen/Jarry

Andersen is over Jarry depending where Andersen goes, Jarry is right now over Andersen if you need to make the choice today.

Agree with this
Hopefully you can just wait.

[Axeman33]

Lehner for me, no matter who goes where.

[Feenom]

Lehner
Jarry
Andersen

[rufio.85]

Lehner is a great goalie but if Fleury is still in Vegas next year, I’m going with Jarry. His spot is secure and he has shown that he was no fluke. Pens still have a couple of elite seasons in them in my opinion.

[senryu]

Lehner
Jarry
Andersen

This would be my order.

[2014olympicgold]

Well Andersen is set to play tonight. Maybe you can jump on the start to trade Andersen to someone while there's some hype around Andersen again.

[pmorrow]

That's funny, I have a very similar decision to make. I have Andersen, Lehner and Jarry (and two Car goalies) and I need to decide whether to keep 1 or 2 of them at most. I am going to wait until after free agency to see where the dust settles. Jarry is making a strong case to be kept over Freddy unless Freddy lands somewhere good, but even before his injuries he was playing really poorly. FA has the better track record than TJ but TJ is a lot younger and had the better year. Lehner is an annoying keep with MAF there - but I am leaning towards keeping him as well. (I doubt I keep one of the Car goalies but you never know how things could shake out. But I wouldnt be shocked if they do a tandem thing again with Mrazek and Ned.)

My gut feeling today is
Lehner
Jarry
Andersen

But they're not miles apart from each other. They all have question marks around them, whether its playing time, consistency or health.

[finnys_fanatsy]

i also like

Lehner
Jarry
Andersen

[pmorrow]

I wonder how Jarry's performance impacts the Pens offseason. Jarry and DeSmith both under contract and could both still be there post-Kraken draft, so it could be one of those things the Pens look at but don't do anything about in the end.

Certainly it has me hoping that Freddy lands a solid gig so I don't even have to consider Jarry. And damn, Nedeljkovic is quickly becoming a consideration - perhaps already passing Jarry in the depth chart. All still too many balls in the air right now to decide but it will be fun to watch the game of musical chairs.

[senryu]

If Carolina is choosing Nedelkjovic and he's winning series and they gave him the regular season starts to ensure he'd avoid becoming an RFA, it seems he's primed to at least be a 50% starter next year at minimum, with perhaps up to 50-55 starts. I don't see how they bring someone else in to squeeze him out.

[Fighting_Emu]

Lehner ike crazy!!! So underrated right now. Hes gonna win a lot of leagues this year...

[havanablast21]

Lehner for me, no matter who goes where.

This right here for me.

I’ve seen enough out of Andersen the last couple seasons to bet on “bust” rather than “boom” for Andersen in a new location especially if a team makes the ill advised decision to follow Florida’s lead and overpay for Andersen.

Still a serviceable G but more so if he chooses to play where he can succeed most over $’s.

If he goes to a team with a strong D, I think he regains some form and ends up being a top 10-12 G. If he follows the $’s and cents inspite of fit (Edm for example) I think both team and G will be in for 3-5 more years of mediocrity/declining results.

Lehner > Andersen and Andersen>\=Jarry because we know where Jarry is playing but this shifts with Andersen’s move.

Lehner remains #1 regardless of the other goalies.

[CaptainCanuck]

Lehner will at worst get 60% of Vegas starts and they are by far the best team for your stats. If it weren't for his injury early this year, he would of been their #1 all year long.