Looking at next week's schedule, I'm not touching any of Gibson, Hill, or Petersen.
Your restrictions make this interesting. Talbot is the number one option for me. Since you can only use two for the week, and one per night, you want someone who plays when Minny doesn't (Tues, Thurs and Sun next week). Bob is a good complement as they play Tues Thurs Sat, albeit with a difficult schedule. Toronto also fits the bill, but Andersen may not be back. Other good options for next week if available would be one of Boston's young guys Vladar or Swayman (assuming Rask still isn't back), or Vanecek with the Caps.
With only being able to use 2 goalies for the week, it's almost a moot point if you're just going to roll with Talbot and Bob, whose schedules align quite nicely with each other. May be best to just hold onto what you got.