Sid & M Tkachuk for Marner.

[Rhem]

All cats banger league. Which side wins? Keeper league.

[newper114]

More league info will help but based on Banger league gotta go with Tkachuk here.

[4T2]

Definitely need more info on the league. Settings, number of keepers, etc... But I don't think there would be too many scenarios where I don't pick the Crosby/Tkachuk side

[Rhem]

G, A, Pts, plus minus, ppp, shp, Pims, hits, GWG.
Keep 4 guys.
I’m already keeping Point, Kucherov, Vasilevsky.

[Kofax]

G, A, Pts, plus minus, ppp, shp, Pims, hits, GWG.
Keep 4 guys.
I’m already keeping Point, Kucherov, Vasilevsky.

And that's why we needed more information. Keep 4, Marner is the best player in the deal by a large margin, makes this trade much less attractive.

Are you in contention? Really, unless this gets you the win this year, keep Marner.

[Rhem]

I have Tkachuk and Sid. I’m trying to get Marner

[pmorrow]

Seems like an overpayment to me in-season, but yes you would get the better keeper. This would hurt your chances of winning though pretty badly wouldnt it?

[Rhem]

I have Tarasenko coming off IR so he would fill the roster spot too

[havanablast21]

try to move crosby and Tank and keep Tkachuk with Marner.

[Rhem]

I can only keep 4 guys. So I would have to move Point in that case. And I feel like Point with Kucherov next year might be better than Marner

[Rhem]

Any other opinions?

[stevegamer]

Tkachuk fits your categories well. I'd be open to moving Point & Crosby instead. That's a big move to load up for next year, though. If you are in contention, I might prefer to move Kucherov. Good luck with whatever you decide.

[Rhem]

Isn’t Point & Sid for Marner way too much tho? Point and Marner are pretty even once Kucherov comes back no?

[stevegamer]

Isn’t Point & Sid for Marner way too much tho? Point and Marner are pretty even once Kucherov comes back no?

Honestly, Crosby & Tkachuk is also a lot to give up. Way too much is up to everyone's interpretation, but it seems like you're already wanting to give up a lot. Giving up Kucherov at least helps you this year, but it's all up to what you prefer, generally you know your league best.

We still don't know if you break out forward spots, which helps Marner, Kucherov, & Tkachuk .

[j0hn_d0e]

I dont liek this at all. Just keep what you have. Even when Tank returns you should keep him on your IR for some time just to see how is gonna perform.