Byram or Seider?

[HonkyTonkMan]

Byram's skill level is off the chart and far superior to Seider's. Seider is an excellent player but skill wins out every time. For me this isn't a case of clear path its a case of the cream rises to the top. Byram is amazing and will produce regardless.

Agreed... choosing the easier path is like drafting for position rather than best player available

[senryu]

Someday, Byram will probably be on a team where Makar is not on that team. When that happens, Byram could be Hedman-like. Until then, he's looking to be Sergachev-like. Seider will never be a top 10 d-man in your system. If you're playing dynasty, then it has to be Byram.

[Kawee]

Yep, it is a dynasty. Thank you everyone, I can see arguments for both sides! Just wanted to see where the majority was at with both of these D men.