Garland or Dvorak

[1320kid]

Who would you rather own ROS under the following format?

H2H points league:
Goals 1
Assist .75
SOG .1
Hat trick 3
SHG 1
SHA .75
PIM .25
PPG .5
PPA .25
Hits .25
block shots .1

[hockeyrobot]

I'm taking Garland here.

[chuckcouples]

I prefer Dvorak as I think his upside is higher.

[tweetdrivr]

Throw a dart - it really doesn't matter. Their stats are the same and should remain that way. The underlying numbers slightly favor Garland. Very slightly. I really don't think there is anything to separate them aside from which one you like more.

[1320kid]

I think I’ll go Garland as well. Thanks for the input all.

[Araziza]

Posted this elsewhere, same question, you have a few other categories, but I think the following still applies:
If it’s points only and no position, I’d take Garland. Dvorak’s shooting percentage is 21% and his power play IPP is 100 percent. These are both going to regress. Garland’s ipp at all strengths is pretty appropriate and even a bit low for one of the team’s top players, and he shoots a ton, so the points should keep coming and possibly even rise a tiny bit. His shooting percentage is 12.5%, which is still a bit high but actually fairly in line with his historical numbers. I’d go Garland here.

[lucafen4]

Funnily enough I covered both back to back in my geek of the week column the past two weeks

this might help: https://dobberhockey.com/category/ho...k-of-the-week/

[j0hn_d0e]

I would take my chances with Garland.