Drop Sergachev for McAvoy or Barrie? (will gladly rep responses)

[kbro]

I tried to edit and bump an old Sergachev thread I posted, but it looks like the edited thread title doesn't display on the forum, so I'm starting a new thread.

Would you drop Sergachev for McAvoy or Barrie? I'm leaning towards McAvoy given his current PP spot and success, but I'm worried Grzelcyk will re-take that spot as soon as he returns to the lineup. Barrie has lost the spot and is cold right now, but it could just be Toronto all over again, where early on there's some adjusting but eventually he settles in there. Maybe the move is McAvoy for now, then a quick jump to Barrie if he gets the spot back. I wouldn't wanna miss that boat though. I'm in a spot where I can be patient, and I'm most interested in H2H playoff production. Thoughts?

I grabbed Sergachev super late in the draft hoping Tampa would use him more on the PP, and that hasn't really seemed to happen. It's an 18 team league but it's pretty shallow because each team only owns two blueliners, so there are decent options out there.

Note the scoring settings: G = 2, A = 2, +/- = 0.5 (positive or negative, I hate this, but it does add value to guys like Sergachev), and PIM = 0.25

Here are my other FA options to replace Sergachev:

- Tyson Barrie
- Charlie McAvoy
- Keith Yandle
- Rasmus Andersson
- Rasmus Ristolainen
- Josh Morrissey
- Filip Hronek
- Alexander Romanov
- Noah Dobson

Thoughts?

I'll gladly rep any responses - thanks for your input!

[renello]

Andersson, Dobson, hronek, Yandle all probably better this year than barrie. McAvoy good option but as you said Grz may shrink value. I am sure some good responses will come for you.

[hockeyrobot]

I think I keep Sergachev here. Barrie might have been the only guy I drafted ahead of him and we know how that's gone. Remember that Tampa has only played 4 games.