Svechnikov/Podkolzin or Kaprizov/Shesterkin

[DudeImJason]

All players aside from Svechnikov are minors eligible up until 100gp then the GM has to decide to call up or drop.

which side would you prefer long term?

[Belexus75]

is this points only league? if it is i think its easy for Kaprizov / Igor side

If its multicat here is my take:

i love svechnikov and podkolzin brings similar element...but im not sure he will ever have offensive upside as other 2 forwards in this deal. So i think you looking at Star + very good useful player for a Star + Star or possible superstar in Igor.

So either way i think i would just Kaprizov/Igor side...but man Svechnikov is a nice player!

[mjm44]

svech side, he is the best player in the deal, shesty looks good but people forget that he has never been a number 1 over a long season, Svech is pure stud , that being said more info might change ones opinions, it says in sig points league? so what are the goalie stats, if they are weighed more heavy than points the conversation changes

[JayJJeffery]

Svech side for me, Podkolzin looks like he could be Svech 2.0 when he comes over.

Kaprizov hasn't played in the NHL, nor has Podz.

So for me it's Svech vs Shesty and Svech wins by a long shot - unless goalie cats are heavily favored and you need a goalie.

[Sawch]

As much as I love me some Kaprizov and Shesty, I like the Svech side. He’s the best player here and is a star in the making.

[DudeImJason]

League stats

g(3)a(2)ppg/shg(1)ppa/sha(0.5)pim(0.3)+/-(0.2)gwg(0.5)fow(0.1)fol(-0.1)hat trick(1)sog(0.3)hit(0.3)bs(0.3)

goalie stats
w(2)l(-2)so(2)ga(-0.5)sv(0.2)otl(-1.5)

[Kofax]

Is this for one of the leagues in your sig? Looks like the first league (16 team) given the players. Trying to find out how much value a goaltender holds vs the forwards. If it's only 1G slot per team as indicated, G value is suppressed a bit, plus you already have Vasilevsky, so you don't really have a pressing need at the position. Not to mention goaltenders are more volatile than skaters, so I would be devaluing Shesterkin in these leagues.

So, given the above, Svechnikov is the best player in the deal and there's another solid prospect there, so I'm taking that side.

[DudeImJason]

Yeah it’s for the first team in my SIG

[stevegamer]

I take the Svechnikov side, mostly because you already have a stud goalie, and once you get Svech, you can then flip another lesser forward with high name value for another goalie, if needed.

I'm guessing this frees up Arvidsson/Gaudreau level forwards for you to deal.

[Avs31]

Gotta be svech side with already having Vas in a start 1G league.

[Axeman33]

It would have to be something pretty crazy for me to trade Shesterkin. In a point only format, Svechnikov isn't crazy enough for me. I'd personally keep what you have.

[Avs31]

I think Svech has 100 pts potential. Also your stats are more multi cat than pts only

[Belexus75]

I think Svech has 100 pts potential. Also your stats are more multi cat than pts only

he is great talent, love the way he plays for 100 pts?i dont see that...

[[email protected]]

I definitely think the kid has 100pt potential...

[Axeman33]

I think Svech has 100 pts potential. Also your stats are more multi cat than pts only

Having 100pt potential, and actually getting to 100pts are two totally different things.