Stone vs Fiala

[The Hitchhiker]

Have Stone penciled into my last keeper spot but have this nagging feeling I should hold onto Fiala who looks poised to breakout. Keep 5. Other keepers are Point, Eichel, Marchand, Hamilton.

[Sawch]

I love Fiala and his potential breakout, but keep Stone.

[Moses]

Proven over potential. I’d keep Stone.

[hockeyrobot]

Keep Stone and if you really want Fiala, redraft him a little earlier than expected.

[j0hn_d0e]

Stone's value is higher at this point. You could keep Stone and then trade him right away for a better winger than Fiala.

[Axeman33]

I agree, Stone for me.

[SeaDawg]

in a 10 team, keep 5 league, I don't think Fiala is a keeper. I'm not sure Stone is either, tbh. If I'm compiling a list of the top 50 players in the NHL, neither Stone nor Fiala are on that list. If I were you, I'd be looking to package Stone and Fiala to get a top 50 player.

If that isn't possible, keep Stone.

[Belexus75]

i dont think Fiala is a keeper either but i think he maybe next year....either keep him and take a chance, or keep stone and try to redraft Fiala asap...

[tweetdrivr]

Stone over Fiala. It would be helpful to see your roster overall - see what else you might have to offer advice. Is draft pick trading allowed?

[Moses]

in a 10 team, keep 5 league, I don't think Fiala is a keeper. I'm not sure Stone is either, tbh. If I'm compiling a list of the top 50 players in the NHL, neither Stone nor Fiala are on that list. If I were you, I'd be looking to package Stone and Fiala to get a top 50 player.

If that isn't possible, keep Stone.

Now this is an interesting idea... I’d like to see what you could get with this offer. Hmmmm

[Dr.Brad]

in a 10 team, keep 5 league, I don't think Fiala is a keeper. I'm not sure Stone is either, tbh. If I'm compiling a list of the top 50 players in the NHL, neither Stone nor Fiala are on that list. If I were you, I'd be looking to package Stone and Fiala to get a top 50 player.

If that isn't possible, keep Stone.

This only works if another GM is so weak that they’ll keep both Fiala and Stone. Who, I ask, would trade you either Tkachuk, or Hedman, or Heiskanen, or Guentzel - if it meant they were dropping one of Stone or Fiala anyway?

[SeaDawg]

This only works if another GM is so weak that they’ll keep both Fiala and Stone. Who, I ask, would trade you either Tkachuk, or Hedman, or Heiskanen, or Guentzel - if it meant they were dropping one of Stone or Fiala anyway?

Yes, it only works if that's the case. I thought that was obvious.

[lucafen4]

You hope Fiala reaches Stone's level in the next couple years. that should make the decision easy.

I doubt you can do a 2-1 for these two in a 12tm league. But doesn't mean - don't try.