Rank Em Please!

[Southpaw20]

Hey all, in a 12 team keeper and hoping you guys can help me out with my last keeper(s). How would you rank the following players in a league counting G, A, +/-, Hit, SOG, PPP?

Josi
Brady Tkachuk
Bergeron
Seguin
Theodore

I am a little thin on D so thinking Josi is on top for me but wanted to hear some other thoughts.

Thanks!

[Big Baby]

Tkachuk
Josi
Seguin
Bergeron
Theodore

That’s how I’d rank them.

Tkachuk is a shot beast and he hits. Has all the best deployment His plus minus might hurt you a bit.

I think he’s about to break out big

[Axeman33]

Tkachuk is the best on that list for me. From there I'd say:

Seguin
Josi
Bergeron
Theodore

[Rocky71]

Josi for me. I rank him above the rest.

[Wotan]

If you say you're a little thin on D, it's Josi at no.1 anyway. Heck he was argueably the second best D to own last season, so it should be him regardless. And yes, I'm obviously biased when it comes to Switzerland's captain. For me the order is exactly the one you've put in your post (but I'll put in some gaps for rough tiers):

Josi
B.Tkachuk


Bergeron
Seguin (maybe swap the rank with Bergeron if age is a more important factor for you)


Theodore

[Zorro]

Josi(thin on D)
B.Tkachuk(multi-cat beast)
Seguin
Bergeron
Theodore

How many keepers are you allowed? Who else are you keeping?

[Southpaw20]

It is a bit of a confusing situation but basically my keepers (keep 6), as of now, look like:
Malkin (C)
Ovy (LW)
Landeskog (C,LW)
Seguin (C,RW)
Andersen (G)
Brady (LW)

Looks like I can swap Brady for Josi if I want. I am tempted as Josi is a top tier Dman and I really have no other options on D. I also have two potential LW options that could make my keeper list aside from Brady.

I hesitate to add this confusion, but Yahoo rankings also come into play. We are only allowed to keep:
1 player ranked 1-12 overall (1st round)
2 players ranked 13-24 (2nd round)
2 ranked 24-36 (3rd round)
2 ranked 36-48 (4th round)
These are based on pre-ranks heading into next season so it would be largely guesswork as to where these players will fall....which is why I did not bring it up in the original post. FWIW I figure Ovy as a 1st rounder, maybe Malkin and Seguin in 2nd, Josi and Freddie in 3rd? Josi should rise from last year's ranking and Seguin should fall a bit I would think

[Wotan]

I'd be surprised if Seguin went already in the 2nd round after the disappointing season he's had. I'd say OV is still a 1st, Josi and Malkin a 2nd (Josi because GMs usually don't pick a D in the 1st), Brady and Seguin potentially in the 3rd, maybe Anderssen too if that goalie run starts rather early. But that's just me - it's not even necessarily my own priorities, it's simply what I think could be a good guess when I take the usual GMs priorities into consideration.

[mjm44]

id keep both josi and tkachuck, let malkin go, I may even consider keeping Theodore over seguin, depending how important d is