Trade Evaluation

[Araziza]

What's the verdict on this trade ROS.
Side A: P.Kane + M.A. Fleury
Side B: D. Perron + A. Vasilevsky

And if the situation would be worse and Side B would only do Tatar, not Perron, would the trade still be good?

[Eskimo Brother]

I definitely wouldn't do it for Tatar. Still on the fence with Perron in there.

Would be interested to hear your reasoning for a bit of context.

[Araziza]

I'm first overall in my league in shots and points, second in both goals and assists. My goaltending leaves much to be desired. Fleury is a russian roulette-esque start, he could get a shutout or just blow up my week. Khudobin never starts. Grubauer has had ups and downs, and was juuuust starting to be awesome when he went out with an injury. I'm walking a tightrope trying to bench my goalies in bad situations but still make 3 starts. I figured Vasilevsky is a massive upgrade on Fleury, and Perron is probably a downgrade on Kane, but maybe not by as much. I'm in first place overall in my league with a decent cushion, but I'm feeling the squeeze a bit (My top 5 picks were Kane, Karlsson, Fleury, Eichel and Guentzel. E.Karlsson and J. Guentzel are gone and Fleury has been a bit of a tire fire).

In any case, it's moot, as my trade deadline was yesterday.

[Eskimo Brother]

Ah, sorry for the late reply then. Hopefully you found something to improve your goaltending!