Help ! Mega blockbusters, McDavid, Kucherov etc.

[Grapes]

Keep 6, Keep 6

Not a cash league. Not contending. Looking at next year.
Thank you in advance for reading through this list of trade offers.

5 offers received from the top teams:
Rounds 1-6 for keepers, 7-9 can’t be traded, 10-20 can be traded
From #1 team:
1: Kane, Trocheck, 13rd pick for my Kucherov , Bergeron, 20rd pick.
2: Kane, Trocheck, Binnington, 10rd pick for my Kucherov, Bergeron, Vasilevskiy, 18rd pick.
From #4 team:
3: Crosby, Q.Hughes, Samsonov for my Bergeron, Pionk, Vasilevskiy
From #2 team:
4: Carlson, Pageau, Schwartz for my Scheifele, Connor, Pionk.
5: McDavid, Marchand, Hoffman, Shattenkirk, Yandle for my MacKinnon, Kucherov, Niskanen, Connor, Pionk

#1. I prefer Kucherov to Kane. Bergeron could be a Keeper. Pick upgrade is ok.
#2. No way. The pick would be about 36 after keepers. Kucherov, Vasilevskiy for Kane, Binnington.
#3. Giving up Vasilevskiy to get Crosby & Samsonov as keepers.
#4. Basically getting Carlson for Scheifele which I like.
#5. Keeper implication becomes his McDavid, Marchand for my MacKinnon, Kucherov. I’d love to remove the Kucherov/Marchand piece because Connor, Pionk, Niskanen is an improvement over the spare parts he’s offering.

Thoughts ?

[LawMan]

I'd do #5 in a heartbeat. If your not in it the keeper implications are all that matter and McDavid + Marchand is >> MacKinnon + Kucherov.

[Eskimo Brother]

I'd do #5 in a heartbeat. If your not in it the keeper implications are all that matter and McDavid + Marchand is >> MacKinnon + Kucherov.

I agree with that, though I also like getting Carlson.

[Grapes]

Thanks LawMan.

He’s lat the Championship this year and I’m looking to next year. He’s offering McDavid only because of the injury. Which makes complete sense.
I’m not much of a Marchand fan. However am I better off with the Kucherov/ Marchand swap or would it be better to swap my Scheifele for Carlson instead if that were an option ?

[Grapes]

Thanks EB.

The Carlson and McDavid offers came from the same owner.
I could always add Scheifele for Carlson to the offer.


I’d be giving up MacKinnon, Kucherov, Scheifele for McDavid, Marchand, Carlson if that were the case.

[Rockies & Hockeys]

1) No, 2) No, 3) 60% Yes, 4) No, 5) 80% Yes

[Grapes]

Accepted the McDavid offer as is plus a draft pick up grade. Also agreed to discuss Carlson after the league playoffs.

- - - Updated - - -

Sent Rep where I could. Thank you everyone. Cheers

[stevegamer]

Combine #4 & 5 into something like:

McDavid, Carlson, Pageau, Schwartz, Shattenkirk for MacKinnon, Scheifele, Connor, Pionk, Niskanen. Tweak the non-keeper pieces, and get the 2 guys you want.