Shesterkin vs. Elvis

[jackalope]

I have Hellebyuck already, and looking for a 2nd goalie to keep in a keep 5.

I own both of these young guys (traded for them both this year at s discount prices).

Which one do you suggest?

Too early to trade Hellebuyck and keep both these 2 guys?

[stevegamer]

I think it's slightly too early, as one of them may not be the starter. That said, I'd be pretty leery of keeping 2 goalies in a keep 5, unless you have no other good options. I would definitely deal one or two of them, might be best to shop them all.

What does your whole roster look like?

[jackalope]

It is common to keep 2 goalies in the pool. So it would not be out of line.

My Offensive keepers would be MdD, Pasta, and Point in a 10 team league.

Other possible keepers would be K. Connor, Hall, Vrana.

I don't think I can trade any of the 3 for the time being as I need them to catch up in G categories.

Only way I'd trade Hellebuyck to keep the other 2 would be to package Hellebuyck and Point for someone better than Point. If I feel I can no longer catch 1st place (currently 2nd).