Blockbuster Keeper Trade

[AlexB13]

I have been given two options..im wondering if i should do one or the other or None at all.

Trade 1-

I trade:
Jack Eichel
Brayden schenn
Pekka Rinne
Jacob Markstrom
2nd round pick this year
2nd round pick this year


I receive:
Tyler Seguin
Matthew Tkachuk
Andrei Vasilevsky
4th round pick this year
5th round pick this year

Trade 2-

I trade:
Jack Eichel
Evander Kane
Pekka Rinne
Jacob Markstrom
2nd round pick this year
2nd round pick this year

I receive:
Tyler Seguin
Andrei Svechnikov
Andrei Vasilevsky
4th round pick this year
5th round pick this year


3 year keeper, head to head categories. Any 3 players can be kept on each team with no restrictions. No other keeper rules.
Forward categories are:
Goals, assists, +-, PPP, SHP, SOG, Hits

Goalie categories are:
Wins, saves, GAA, SV%, Shutouts


My team:
Schenn
Eichel
Gaudreau
E. kane
Kucherov
Rantanen


Defenseman:
Letang
Gudas
Borowiecki
Fox

Bench:
Debrincat
Wheeler
Hoffman
E.Kane

Goalies:
Marc-Andre Fleury
Pekka Rinne
Jacob markstrom
Ilya samsonov
Petr Mrazek

IR:
Olofsson

Next years draft i have:
1st
(2) 2nd round picks
-NO 3rd-
-NO 4th-
5th
6th
7th
-NO 8th-
(2) 9th round picks
10th
11th
-NO 12th-
13th
(2) 14th round picks
15th
16th
17th
18th

[Axeman33]

The first question I have is how, in your opinion, will this affect your keepers in such a limited keeper? With your current team as it is today, who are your three keepers?

If you were to do either of these deals, does Seguin now become a keeper for your? Vasilevskiy? Both? If you are giving away better picks, along with quality players, you best be upgrading your keepers.

[AlexB13]

My keepers atm are:
Kucherov
Eichel
Fleury/rantanen

If i made this trade my keepers would then be:
Kucherov
Seguin/rantanen
Vasilevsky

I just feel with vas and fleury id take over goalie categories week by week. Im going all in this year

[finnys_fanatsy]

Either trade upgrades your keepers but also see you moving out serious talent. No real preference to either but I do like the looks of trade 2 more

[MZac]

I don't hate it as a win now move but I tremendously dislike giving up the best player in eichel. With 5 goalie cats I suppose you can argue that Vas is the best player. I also really generally dislike keeping goalies in a keep 3, but almost half your cats are for goalies so there is some merrit and if you are going to keep one Id want it to be Vas.

Overall if you think it helps you win this year then I'm alright with it. If you do it I'd keep kuch, Vas, and either rant or Seguin (Heavily lean towards rant if forward positions count and if they don't it's close and I'd wait to decide).

Edit: if you do it I'd take the one that gives you svechnikov.