McDavid for Makar and Rantanen

[jonsealey]

League in signature, in a points only I think I should keep McDavid but I am high on Rantanen and Makar is just playing amazingly right now.

I would drop Hronek or Gus to make this happen.

10 Team Keep 7 + 1 Rookie
Point's: 1 G 1 A 1.5 W 1.5 SO
Start:10 fs, 4 D, 1 Goalies
Daily lineups

Forwards:
MacKinnon, McDavid, Aho, Teuvo, Baile, Nino, Getzlaf, Zibanajed, Buchnevich, Hoffman, Zucker, Kerfoot, Krejci, Gusev
Defenseman:
Karlsson, Gustaffson, Letang, Krug, Hronek

Goaltenders:
Vas, Binnington

[macker27]

Don't even think about it. He'll anchor your team for the next 10+ years

[MZac]

No signature showing.

On the surface I wouldn't even do this in a one year, definitely not in any type of keeper. Mcdavid is the fantasy player with the highest ceiling right now and an extremely high floor to go along with it. Almost never trade him, to consider it the offer has to all but guarantee you a championship in my opinion and this offer doesn't come close. Keep mcdavid.

[jonsealey]

No signature showing.

On the surface I wouldn't even do this in a one year, definitely not in any type of keeper. Mcdavid is the fantasy player with the highest ceiling right now and an extremely high floor to go along with it. Almost never trade him, to consider it the offer has to all but guarantee you a championship in my opinion and this offer doesn't come close. Keep mcdavid.

Sorry. Showing now.

[redwing401959]

Not a chance i make this trade i love both of those guys but Its McDavid Keep him

[jonsealey]

He has upped the offer to McDavid and Hedman for Rantanen and Makar....In a points only assuming Makar is the real deal it is not as terrible as I thought, but I can't pull the trigger.

[pmorrow]

He has upped the offer to McDavid and Hedman for Rantanen and Makar....In a points only assuming Makar is the real deal it is not as terrible as I thought, but I can't pull the trigger.

Wait do you mean he added Hedman to his Rantanen and Makar offer? I'm confused

Either way, do not move McDavid. You'll regret it. There's plenty of other ways to build up your depth without moving the best keeper player.

[jonsealey]

Sorry I did not word that well.

He now wants McDavid and Hedman for his Rantanen and Makar.

[Dennis]

He can go screw

[Kofax]

Sorry I did not word that well.

He now wants McDavid and Hedman for his Rantanen and Makar.

I was a no on the first one, so this makes it even worse.

In a limited keeper, McDavid is almost untradeable.

[MZac]

Sorry I did not word that well.

He now wants McDavid and Hedman for his Rantanen and Makar.

Easy no without a counter. The other GM is not even close to a fair valuation of McDavid in limited keeper. As a general rule we don't trade mcdavid in limited keepers. If we are to consider it it must all but guarantee us a championship this year or next year, this offer is not even close.

[Gretzky99Orr4]

I wouldn't do this if he threw in his house.

[jonsealey]

Thanks!

Tis what I thought!