Ekblad or Chabot?

[Paddy]

Who would you rather have?

I feel like Chabot will produce more points but his pims and +/- will drag him down.

Ekblad on the other had will soce less but have a better +/- and more pims.

is that a fair comparison? is it a wash?

[lucafen4]

In Fantasy, I like Chabot a lot more than Ekblad.

Not sure what you mean by PIM dragging Chabot down - unless PIM actually count as a negative stat in your pool.

Ekblad seems to be a 40ish pt Dman who yearns to produce more.
Whereas Chabot has a legit 60+pt ceiling and delivers decent periphs as well.

[pmorrow]

I would much rather have Chabot. I don't think Ekblad excels at any category so much more than Chabot to make me want him more than the elite production offensively that Chabot provides.

I see you have Ekblad, are you looking to acquire Chabot? If so I don't think you could get him 1 for 1 but you might not have to add a ton to make it happen depending on the Chabot owner's needs.

[Paddy]

What I meant was, ekblad gets quite a few more pims then chabot.

[toeincrease]

I think it's more of a toss up because Ekblad will have a better + -, more pims, and more hits. Chabot will have a few more goals and most likely a lot more asst.
If Yandle ever goes down Ekblad ( specially this year) would be gold.
Unfortunately Yandle seems to be an iron man.

[pmorrow]

How did the two compare last year in total points in your format (assuming league in the sig)?

[j0hn_d0e]

Who would you rather have?

I feel like Chabot will produce more points but his pims and +/- will drag him down.

Ekblad on the other had will soce less but have a better +/- and more pims.

is that a fair comparison? is it a wash?

Both are helping in different categories. Ekbald actually had just 15 more PIMs than Chabot though. Chabot is about 30 spots higher in the draft rankins and Im willing to target him around 90-100 than waiting for Ekblad at 120-130.

[DusterDave]

I’d go with a Chabot as well.

[pdel21]

My vote for Chabot too!