Trade help

[Morache]

23 man, 20 teams dynasty, keep all. Banger.
Give: Hedman, Bailey
Get: Markstrom, Stone

[PrairieDog]

Depends what your defence and positional requirements look like.

[Moses]

Yup, that is a trade!

I'm not positive what the question is but, before weighing in I want to know what the goalie stats are? Is "SAVES" a CAT and how many goalies start at a time? I am aware of the supply/demand of a 20 team dynasty league when it comes to goaltending. If this is a daily start, 2x goalie, with SAVES as a CAT then this deal is probably not far off of the mark.

I am in a 20 team dynasty weekly H2H daily start, 2x goalie, with SAVES as a CAT and trades that involve a goalie, where only one team is giving up a goalie, can look skewed. But the supply/demand for goalies in this set up league set up places an extreme valve on workhorse starting goalies.

[Morache]

Yup, that is a trade!

I'm not positive what the question is but, before weighing in I want to know what the goalie stats are? Is "SAVES" a CAT and how many goalies start at a time? I am aware of the supply/demand of a 20 team dynasty league when it comes to goaltending. If this is a daily start, 2x goalie, with SAVES as a CAT then this deal is probably not far off of the mark.

I am in a 20 team dynasty weekly H2H daily start, 2x goalie, with SAVES as a CAT and trades that involve a goalie, where only one team is giving up a goalie, can look skewed. But the supply/demand for goalies in this set up league set up places an extreme valve on workhorse starting goalies.

Sorry, should have provided more context. But yeah, goalies are hard to come by for sure. We only have 1x daily G starting position though, with GS, GA, Saves, Shots against as cats. I already own Demko so having both would lock down Vancouver.

[Morache]

Depends what your defence and positional requirements look like.

So my D is pretty stacked with Karlsson, Chabot, Weber, Pietrangelo, Hughes, Lindell and Valimaki other than Hedman.
My goalies are a mess... Kuemper, Anderson, Demko, Francouz.

[stevegamer]

That's too much for Markstrom. His other thread provides a bunch more context. You might want to put your roster in your signature.

[Morache]

That's too much for Markstrom. His other thread provides a bunch more context. You might want to put your roster in your signature.

Yeah had a feeling it was too much, thanks for the reassurance. Yeah that's a good idea, i will update my signature.

[lucafen4]

Agree with stevegamer - it's really hard to valuate a deal without your roster to assist identifying needs.

- - - Updated - - -

I mean, one could break it down - Stone for Hedman - Bailey for Markstrom. Mark Stone has some solid value in MC leagues

[Moses]

I don't mind the deal for you. Locking up a tandem means that every single week (if it is a weekly set up) you have a chance to beat your opponent. Not giving up a goalie while getting one back is huge. Mark Stone is a top 10 fantasy RW. Markstrom was a top 10 goalie last season. You do lose an elite Dman, but you have to give to get. Justin Bailey is not an excellent player in a banger/multi-cat format.

What does give me pause is that the is no guarantee that the Markstrom/Demko duo stays together for more than just this season. The glass-half-full side says, "Great, next year I end up with 2 starters!"... The glass-half-empty side goes, "What the hell am I going to do this season with Griess and Lehner dammit! Why did I give up Debrincat to complete the trade for the tandem?"