Domi or Reinhart?

[habs86]

Who do you like more in a keeper league between Max Domi and Sam Reinhart? I actually traded Reinhart for Brayden Schenn last summer and I think it might be a good time to move Domi as I think he might've peaked last year.

Thoughts?

We count many stats in that league (G, A, +/-, shots, PPP, SHP, GWG and playoffs are also a big factor since we start over for the playoffs with the players who made it. I'm a Habs fan but I'm not sure which of Montreal or Buffalo has more chance to reach the playoffs this year.

[Axeman33]

Welcome to the forums!

Looking at the two, Domi was the better of the two players last season, but I have a strange suspicion that Domi isn't as good as last years numbers show. I can see him coming down a bit and making this a lot closer than it looks like on paper. At this point, I'd probably still want Domi, but I am not expecting another repeat performance like we saw last year. As far as playoffs go, I don't really expect either Montreal OR Buffalo to make it, but I do like what Buffalo has done this off-season, from hiring Ralph Krueger to revamping their roster a bit (and I don't think they are done yet either. They have too many Dmen).

[SeaDawg]

I prefer Reinhart...both teams are unlikely to make the playoffs this coming season...though I like Buffalo's future prospect of making the playoffs more than Montreal's

[PrairieDog]

I like Reinhart - Buffalo is poised to be a team on the rise for the next few years and Rhino will be a big part of that. Domi is solid but I just don't have much faith in Habs management. They are very close but SR's surrounding cast tips the scales for me.

[LuigiC173]

Domi, Reinhart reliant upon others for his production IMO.

[mounD]

I think Reinhart is the safer choice, but Domi does offer some element of all-around upside that Reinhart probably won't match. This is a really tough one, and should be interesting to revisit in a year's time, but I think I'll go with Domi on the homerun swing.

[fungchen3]

I like Domi's upside more... although Reinhart will be steadier.
I'd roll the dice on Domi.

[habs86]

I ended up accepting the deal to bring back Reinhart on my team. We'll see if that was a good call.

Thanks to everyone who replied.