Rank These 3 Centers

[gottheblues]

In a 16 team 9 keeper league with point only system with goals assists being 1 point and pp and overtime goals being 2 points who out of these three who would you rather have if you could only to have one to keep out of Scheifele, Eichel or Petterson going forward the next couple years.

[Axeman33]

Ew, tough one.

I'd say Scheifele is the odd man out for me here.

[BlackhawksFan]

Yeah....tough decision. i say Pettersson.

[CMSpiced]

Scheifele is certainly the odd one out for me.

I think Petterson has the highest ceiling between him and Eichel, so I would go with him IMO.

[Eskimo Brother]

I want to say Eichel, but I can't fault an AP selection either. That being said, over the next four years it wouldn't surprise me if Scheifele has the most total points.

[senryu]

For the next couple of years, Scheifele

[redwing401959]

Man that is like asking what one of your kids you want to keep LOL and i cant decide... either Petterson or Eichel

[hockeymanG23]

Eichel for me.

[EnglishJet]

Wow this is tough... The Jets fan in me wants to say Fefe, but logically I know it's between the other two. Short-term Eichel but the long-term potential lies with Petterson.,

[mounD]

This one feels like throwing darts, but I'll say Eichel > Pettersson > Scheifele. Winnipeg situation kinda worries me a bit with their current defense, so I think I'd probably choose between Eichel and EP.

[GavinC]

Pettersson for me, think he's right there with the others as soon as this season, if not then next. Just what he did with injuries, Boeser injured, and now with more help on the blue line. Think Canuck fans are in for a good time.

[als_revenge]

If you have 9 keepers and 16 teams, I'd love to know who you are keeping that is causing you to drop EP and Scheifele. (I assume you can't trade either, since they are both easily keepers in your set up).

[kingpin_co]

I'm in the minority I suppose but I dont really view Pettersson in that company...

My ranking:
Eichel
Scheifele
Pettersson

[FrozenInferno]

Short term: Eichel - Schiefele - Pettersson

Long term: Eichel/Pettersson - Schiefele

While I don't think Schiefele has quite hit his ceiling yet - I think he's got 85-90pts in him in a peak season with consistent play and no slumps - I think the other two guys have the higher potential and could have multiple 90+ point seasons in time. Eichel as soon as this coming season and Pettersson maybe a couple of years from now.

[j0hn_d0e]

I flipped a coin 10 times and the results are: 4 times the coin landed on Pettersson's name. 3 on Scheifele's name and the other 3 on Eichel's name..... so I'm going with Pettersson.