Dynasty trade , advice please

[Pippin]

League not I needed sig

fantrax 16 team league, h2h, winner of the weekly matchup gets 1 win.
1.5 pts - goal 1 pt - assist, .1 pts for pim/hit/block, +/- .25 for plus minus

cap league , 20 main roster with goalies, bench can be as big as you want, cap is +15 mil over real NHL cap.

the trade in question is:

P.Kane (fantasy pts per game 2.39)
J.Guentzel (fps per game 1.9)

for

S.Crosby (fps per game 2.39)
E.Kane (fps per game 1.89)

salary swap is pretty even, the only glaring difference in value I see is that guentzel is 3 yrs younger than E.Kane. What say you oh dobber gurus

REP given! Cheers

[Eskimo Brother]

The production is eerily similar. You're getting two wings for a C and a W, taking on 0.8M in salary, and losing a few years age wise. If the other guy is coming to you with this deal, I would ask for an extra incentive in dealing Crosby - actually either way I ask for a little more. Sid's production vs cap is the best in the deal.

[Pippin]

I should clarify, I'm being offered Crosby and E.Kane for My P.Kane and Guentzel.

Guentzel is also C/LW/RW

[SeaDawg]

I prefer P. Kane/Guentzel

[lucafen4]

Any chance you can knock it down to 1-1 Sid for Pat ? Having that Pitts duo would be dynamite.

I would rather trust Guentzel vs. E. Kane moving forward