Pick 4 Keepers HELP!!

[flyersffan]

I can keep each player this year, can only keep 4:

Matt Murray - 4th round
John Klingberg - 5th round
Dylan Larkin - 11th round
Jonathan Drouin - 12th round
Mark Stone - 13th round
Brock Boeser - 17th round
Timo Meier 18th round
Jordan Binnington 19th round
Dylan Stome - 20th round


Note: Each player moves up 2 rounds per year kept
eg: Larkin was a 13th rounder in 2018-2019, is a 11th round if kept this year and would be a 9th round pick in 2020-2021.

Cats: G, A, P, +/-, PIMS, PPP, W, GA, SV, SV%, SO

[newper114]

Gotta be honest I don’t fully get the picks situation but based on players I am keeping these 4:

Larkin - because super stud in any format.
Stone
Binnington
Meier

Mainly last 3 guys bc those sound like great value for such late round selections

[Eskimo Brother]

I get the keeper restrictions with the picks as I have played in leagues like this before, and I agree with Newper's choices. Larkin, Stone, Meier, Binnington.

[RizzeeDizzee]

I think Stone, Binnington and Meier are locks. Larkin is probably be "right" fourth keeper, although I wouldn't be shocked if Drouin or Boeser outproduce him this season.

[senryu]

Mark Stone - 13th round
Brock Boeser - 17th round
Timo Meier 18th round
Jordan Binnington 19th round

[Sulla]

How easy is it to land goalies? Looking at the category weighting I’d be tempted to keep 2 but depends on the nuance of goalies here

[SeaDawg]

Dylan Larkin - 11th round
Mark Stone - 13th round
Timo Meier 18th round
Jordan Binnington 19th round

I'd likely keep these four...Binnington over Boeser for me, though I suppose this depends on how many teams are in your league and the odds of being able to re-draft a goalie. Personally, I don't ever like going into a draft without a goalie (in most leagues).

[HonkyTonkMan]

I'm also on team Larkin, Meier, Binnington, Stone

[flyersffan]

Goalies are taken fairly high, last years draft board

Wally Cup (2).jpg

[Sulla]

I’d be tempted to keep both then tbh. Could be hard to upgrade there and with that split of stats a poor goalie selection could kill you

[Eskimo Brother]

I’d be tempted to keep both then tbh. Could be hard to upgrade there and with that split of stats a poor goalie selection could kill you

Only 10 teams though, so it's unlikely the goalies are so necessary that you would have to pass on one of Meier, Stone, or Larkin at their draft slot.

[SeaDawg]

I wouldn't keep Murray. You lose one of Meier, Stone, or Larkin plus a 4th round pick.

I bet you can keep those three forwards and re-draft Murray (or a comparable goalie) in the 4th round.

[flyersffan]

This was my thinking, needed some reassurance.

[Sulla]

Possibly - I’d just feel more comfortable picking up 60 point forwards than good goalies and I think the drop off of 10 points here or there is more easy to make up - but as I say just my opinion

[stevegamer]

The way I see it is that it's 4 of these 5 guys:

Dylan Larkin - 11th round
Mark Stone - 13th round
Brock Boeser - 17th round
Timo Meier 18th round
Jordan Binnington 19th round

I think I'd toss Boeser back of those guys, as if he went that late last year, he's likely going that late again. The other 4 are much more likley to get drafted before you can keep them. Klingberg is fair value where he is, but you want bargains in leagues like this.

Do NOT keep Murray.