Ehlers vs Fiala in pts only - rep

[cheese_cake]

I've received an offer for Ehlers that would get me Fiala + a 4th rd pick. Do I do it? Is Ehlers so much better than Fiala in the end?

The league is not the one in sig: 12 team, 25 men rosters, start 9F, 4D, 2G weekly and its points-only. Keep 12.

I'm open to trading Ehlers because I wonder if he ever is going to reach his potential where Fiala is probably going to get every chance to shine since they traded for him (but seems to have a lower ceiling).
I also have the possibility to trade him for veterans in the form of Benn or Giroux - would that be better?

[rufio.85]

I would definitely trade Ehlers for Giroux, but not for Fiala.
Back-to-back 60+ seasons with solid underlying numbers for Ehlers are the reasons why.
Even with prime opportunity, Fiala couldn't do much in Minnesota.

EDIT: this offer for Ehlers really feels like a buying-low case...

[stevegamer]

I'd rather have Giroux than Ehlers for sure. Fiala no.

[Eskimo Brother]

Giroux >> Ehlers >> Fiala.

[cheese_cake]

Thanks all, I could only rep rufio unfortunately.

[saucelife90]

I made this exact same trade in my points only pool near the start of this season. I was the one getting Ehlers however, and I haven't looked back.

Like the above posters mentioned, Giroux > Ehlers > Fiala.

[j0hn_d0e]

Giroux over Ehlers over Fiala - case closed

[Axeman33]

I think Fiala is going to bounce back and is a buy-low right now but I still prefer Ehlers over him. I'd take Giroux over Ehlers.

[roenick27]

Is there a cap implication? That would change things a little here, but even still, I think G is just too good to pass up on in points only.

[ericdaoust]

Giroux >> Ehlers >> Fiala.

This ^^^