Who's my 4th keeper- Pettersson or Dahlin?

[KingKarl]

you're already keeping Mack & McDavid.
you start 2C - so keeping Pettersson seems nonsensical based purely on that.
in a keep 4 - you can't keep 3 pure C's when only 2 start.

Yes I hear you, but we also have a forward Utility slot to start every day so I was thinking he'd go there as my 3rd C, would that change anything? But you guys make a good point, I can see how Carlson might be the best option for next year.. well see how they finish up the season.

[KingKarl]

Am I crazy to think keeping Kessel or Carlson is the right move here?

Not at all, I was thinking Kessel would be my 4th keeper at the beginning of the season like the previous 2, but he was playing on 3rd line alot this year, he's no longer stuck to Malkin all the time, and he's constantly in trade rumors. Plus he'll be 32 next year, and even though he's still a beast and producing, I'm thinking with Marner as my elite RW keeper already, another player might be a better option. And Carlson seems to be other people's top pick, might be keeping him as my last keeper instead and let Kessel go this year.

[chuckcouples]

As much as I prefer proven over potential, Dahlin is the guy that I would keep.

[lucafen4]

Yes I hear you, but we also have a forward Utility slot to start every day so I was thinking he'd go there as my 3rd C, would that change anything? But you guys make a good point, I can see how Carlson might be the best option for next year.. well see how they finish up the season.

something like - Carlson 68pts, Dahlin 41.

It doesn't change my mind on Pettersson in this format.... sadly.. I'm a huge fan.

[KingKarl]

something like - Carlson 68pts, Dahlin 41.

It doesn't change my mind on Pettersson in this format.... sadly.. I'm a huge fan.

Ok I see. Thanks for the input!