Gaudreau/Mackinnom trade help!

[Avs31]

Need help on potential trades I could accept.

I would get Gaudreau for Keller, Provorov and 1st rnd rookie(prob. 3rd ovr or 2nd)

Or

I would get Mackinnon for Keller, Provorov, 1st rd rookie(same as above) and Tolvanen or Heiskanen, 1st rd rookie and Keller

Thinking Gaudreau cuz price is less but Im an Avs fan lol and I already have Rantanen and Landy lol Age gap is also close


Thoughts?


— — — — — — — — — — —
9 Team Keeper League(keep 30 at end of yr)
Points(4), PIM(.5) and +/-(.5)

Roster:
15 F
7D
3G
12Farm
5Jr spots

Rantanen , E. lindholm, Rakell, Johnsson, Marner, Dubois, Keller, M. Tkachuk, Couturier, Bratt, Landeskog,, A. Svechnikov, Chytil, Eriksson Ek

Heiskanen, Provorov, Montour, Hanifin, Parayko, Morrissey, Girard

Holtby, Bobrovsky , Saros

Kaprizov, Dunn, Pulock, Ullmark, Pilut, Sprong, Joseph, W. Karlsson, Dzingel, Greenway,Binnington, Kunin,Compher

Vilardi, Tolvanen, Timmins, Bermstrom, Bokk

Subban

[Axeman33]

I am a little confused on the 2nd offer as you have Keller in there twice. The part where you say after the comma, 1st round rookie and Keller.

Just for clarity, the 2nd offer for MacKinnon is Keller, Provorov, 1st and one of Heiskanen or Tolvanen?

[pmorrow]

Need help on potential trades I could accept.

I would get Gaudreau for Keller, Provorov and 1st rnd rookie(prob. 3rd ovr or 2nd)

Or

I would get Mackinnon for Keller, Provorov, 1st rd rookie(same as above) and Tolvanen or Heiskanen, 1st rd rookie and Keller

Thinking Gaudreau cuz price is less but Im an Avs fan lol and I already have Rantanen and Landy lol Age gap is also close


Thoughts?


— — — — — — — — — — —
9 Team Keeper League(keep 30 at end of yr)
Points(4), PIM(.5) and +/-(.5)

Roster:
15 F
7D
3G
12Farm
5Jr spots

Rantanen , E. lindholm, Rakell, Johnsson, Marner, Dubois, Keller, M. Tkachuk, Couturier, Bratt, Landeskog,, A. Svechnikov, Chytil, Eriksson Ek

Heiskanen, Provorov, Montour, Hanifin, Parayko, Morrissey, Girard

Holtby, Bobrovsky , Saros

Kaprizov, Dunn, Pulock, Ullmark, Pilut, Sprong, Joseph, W. Karlsson, Dzingel, Greenway,Binnington, Kunin,Compher

Vilardi, Tolvanen, Timmins, Bermstrom, Bokk

Subban

I prefer Mackinnon for Heiskanen, 1st rd rookie and Keller above the other options.

[Avs31]

My bad. The 2nd offer is basically between Provorov , Keller , the 1st and Tolvanen OR Keller Heiskanen and the 1st...he liked Heiskanen more so basically by swapping Provorov w/Heiskanen I get to keep Tolvanen. - This is for Mackinnon

- - - Updated - - -

Default Re: Gaudreau/Mackinnom trade help!
My bad. The 2nd offer is basically between Provorov , Keller , the 1st and Tolvanen OR Keller Heiskanen and the 1st...he liked Heiskanen more so basically by swapping Provorov w/Heiskanen I get to keep Tolvanen. - This is for Mackinnon

[Axeman33]

My bad. The 2nd offer is basically between Provorov , Keller , the 1st and Tolvanen OR Keller Heiskanen and the 1st...he liked Heiskanen more so basically by swapping Provorov w/Heiskanen I get to keep Tolvanen. - This is for Mackinnon

- - - Updated - - -

Default Re: Gaudreau/Mackinnom trade help!
My bad. The 2nd offer is basically between Provorov , Keller , the 1st and Tolvanen OR Keller Heiskanen and the 1st...he liked Heiskanen more so basically by swapping Provorov w/Heiskanen I get to keep Tolvanen. - This is for Mackinnon

Gotcha. Thanks for the clarity. Honestly, I'd do either trade. I wouldn't let owning two other Av's scare me from getting MacKinnon. The only downfall is you have a lot of off-nights with a lot of guys from the same time playing but in the end, it all adds up.

[Kofax]

I need some clarification here. It looks like it's a keep 9, but do you get to keep your farm? What's the farm eligibility?

If you are able to keep Keller and Provorov outside of your 9 keepers, then I don't make either trade. But if you would have to count Keller and Provorov in your 9 keepers, then I take MacKinnon.

EDIT: I read that wrong, it's keep 30. Personally, I think it's too much to give up. I'm definitely out on the Gaudreau deal. The MacKinnon one I'd think more about.