Hall for Arvidsson

[Fishfrenzy]

Hey there,

I'm in a yahoo pool that counts goals, assists, +/-, PPP, SHP, GWG, SOG, PMs, FW, hits, blocks. I only have 3 IR slots and the following players hurt/suspended: Pasta, EK65, Malkin, Hall, and Ehlers. I'm in a playoff position and would like to reduce my injury count for the playoffs (last 3 weeks of regular season). The last place team (far behind and won't make playoffs) has offered me his healthy Arvidsson for my injured Hall to upgrade his keepers for next season. Our league is a Keep 6. My six keepers last year were Hall, Trocheck, Kuzy, EK65, Pasta, Malkin. If I trade Hall, my sixth keeper would become one of: Arvidsson, O'Reilly, Stone, Risto, Larkin, Pavelski, Bishop, Hart.

What would you do in my position? Would you trade an injured Hall for a healthy Arvidsson? Does anyone think Hall will be back in time for my playoffs?

Thanks in advance.

[snowball]

No, wouldnt do it for Arvidsson. You can get more for Hall if you were to trade him

Malkin is just suspended 1 game
Pasta just out 2 weeks
EK is probably day to day and will be back within 1 week imo
Hall should skate this week, id give him 1 to 2 week tops before he plays a game

So i would stay put as you have 4 guys that will come out IR within the next week or so. Try surviving this week with some good waiver pick up.

Only guys i would consider as a 6th keeper would be Risto or Hart depending on how they perform 2nd half of season.

[stevegamer]

I wouldn't do that.

You have Malkin, who isn't injured, out 1 game. He may get hurt, of course, but he's not hurt now. He shouldn't be IR-eligible, but maybe your league is run that way.

As for your IR bunch:
Karlsson should be back before your playoffs, and possibly this week.
Ehlers is looking like next week, from what I've read.
Pastrnak & Hall likely should return before your playoffs as well, but we're not fully sure.

[Fishfrenzy]

Thx for the answers!

[Doug Glatt]

I would move Malkin now while he is still healthy. 90% chance he's going down again soon. Probably get a better return than Arvidsson too.

[j0hn_d0e]

Hey there,

I'm in a yahoo pool that counts goals, assists, +/-, PPP, SHP, GWG, SOG, PMs, FW, hits, blocks. I only have 3 IR slots and the following players hurt/suspended: Pasta, EK65, Malkin, Hall, and Ehlers. I'm in a playoff position and would like to reduce my injury count for the playoffs (last 3 weeks of regular season). The last place team (far behind and won't make playoffs) has offered me his healthy Arvidsson for my injured Hall to upgrade his keepers for next season. Our league is a Keep 6. My six keepers last year were Hall, Trocheck, Kuzy, EK65, Pasta, Malkin. If I trade Hall, my sixth keeper would become one of: Arvidsson, O'Reilly, Stone, Risto, Larkin, Pavelski, Bishop, Hart.

What would you do in my position? Would you trade an injured Hall for a healthy Arvidsson? Does anyone think Hall will be back in time for my playoffs?

Thanks in advance.

in bold - man, thats bad luck..... If im in your possition considering all the keepers stuff and the coming playoffs
I would try to trade Hall or another injured player for some help in the playoffs. Seeng that Larkin could be a keeper for you makes the things easier - he should be a keeper for you!

[Fishfrenzy]

Bump. How about Hall for Arvidsson and Rask?

[lucafen4]

Do you need a goalie?

side note Arvidsson = 0 PP production

[Leeroy Jenkins]

Rask is pretty meh, imo. Your opponent is just trying to dump him. Unless Rask excels at one or two niche categories, I'd stay away from him and try and get a prospect you can turn around for a more useful centre. Something like that...

[mounD]

no way, my friend. You gotta keep taylor hall in this one.

[Eskimo Brother]

Bump. How about Hall for Arvidsson and Rask?

Assuming Tuukka.
Not a bad deal, but you're selling way low on Hall here. Agree with Luca though that it could depend on how badly you need a goalie.