3 for 3 -- which side?

[hockeyrobot]

Rare 3 for 3 deal in my league with no picks involved and wondering which side you guys like. It's a keep 8 but I don't think there are any major keeper ramifications.

G,A,PPP,SOG,Hits

Team in playoffs gave up Josi, Meier, Kopitar

Team out of playoffs gave up Letang, Krug, Hoffman.

[niconasr]

Depends on the rest of the lineups because it's 2F1D for 2D1F.

The Letang side has a very clear edge on PPP and a slight edge in hits. The Josi side has the edge in SOG. So it basically comes to offense where all those guys are close but I like the upside for Kopitar in these final 25 games and Josi and Meier are on Stanley Cup aspiring teams and should get their offense.

Overall, it's pretty close and I'm not sure I would make this trade either way without knowing about the rest of each team's lineup.

[StuntMan12]

Letang, Krug, Hoffman side

[hockeyrobot]

Depends on the rest of the lineups because it's 2F1D for 2D1F.

The Letang side has a very clear edge on PPP and a slight edge in hits. The Josi side has the edge in SOG. So it basically comes to offense where all those guys are close but I like the upside for Kopitar in these final 25 games and Josi and Meier are on Stanley Cup aspiring teams and should get their offense.

Overall, it's pretty close and I'm not sure I would make this trade either way without knowing about the rest of each team's lineup.

Haha that's all fair. I did not want to say which side I was

I'm the side that got Letang, Hoffman and Krug and Im in 4-6th changing every week. I mainly did it because Nashville and SJ only play 2 games the first week of the playoffs. Call me crazy but the guys I received all play 4. To me that is a big deal when these guys aren't keepers. We shall see.

[MZac]

Most fantasy playoff formats are an 'anyone can win on any given week' type format. Outside of top end talent I'm a firm believer in man games (TOI) being more important than almost anything else. I like the deal for you without more info.

[Axeman33]

I think both teams got some very good pieces, making this trade fairly even. I guess the important thing is you got what you needed.