Atkinson vs Meier

[cheese_cake]

In a pts only pool, who would you take 1) ROS, 2) next year? 12 team, 25 players rosters, start 9F, keep 12 any position. Both would be keepers

[audiopile]

this year atkinson because he has panarin and meier still not consistent.

next year meier because he will be more consistent and atkinson likely won’t have panarin.

[cheese_cake]

Thanks audiopile. Anyone else?

[hockeyrobot]

this year atkinson because he has panarin and meier still not consistent.

next year meier because he will be more consistent and atkinson likely won’t have panarin.

Agree with audiophile. But next year I want Meier because I think he finally gets passed this mid season wall he is sort of hitting. Plus if Pavelski leaves there will be more room on the PP.

[PaulyMcPaul]

Timo Meier is more line dependant than me on weekends back in the early 2000’s. Plus after watching Timo play, there’s a lot of defensive errors he makes and just poor deacision making still. Cam Atkinson is streaky but has produced decent numbers without Panarin. I’d go Atkinson until proven otherwise. If you want to take a risk go with Timo.

[cheese_cake]

In the end I want with Meier, thanks all for the suggestions