For this season : trade Raanta for Dubnyk or Bishop?

[Paquette44]

I'm looking to replace Raanta to make a push for first place, so this year's points are the most important! (2 pts for wins, +1 shutout)

I have an offer for Dubnyk (2nd round pick vs 5th)
I could probably also have Bishop for almost the same price.
For Bobrovsky and Gibson I'm not sure I could have them but it's possible if I make a good offer (more than the previous 2)
Finally, I could try to make a big offer for Hellebuyk but that would cost me alot more but he would be a keeper for a while after!

I need advise lol I'm not sure what I should do... Does it worth it to replace Raanta?
How would you rank these goalies for the remaining of the season?

Thanks

[stevegamer]

I like Dubnyk over Bishop for the same price. Since you aren't looking at keeping the player, I wouldn't look at paying more to get a keeper level goalie, unless you then plan to trade them later to recoup some of your investment.

[captaincrunch32]

I like Dubnyk over Bishop for the same price. Since you aren't looking at keeping the player, I wouldn't look at paying more to get a keeper level goalie, unless you then plan to trade them later to recoup some of your investment.

I agree. The Dallas D is thin and Bishop isn't the Bishop of a few years back. Dub is still in his prime.

[ericdaoust]

Go with Dubnyk

[HonkyTonkMan]

Doesn't get more consistent than Duby

[j0hn_d0e]

Another one for Dubnyk

[DusterDave]

Easily Dubnyk.

[Axeman33]

Doobie is the guy I'd want.