Guentzel or Tuch? Plus goalie advice..

[doesitbumpinthewhip]

So I had a streamer position on my team where I basically streamed a goalie in every week since I only have Varlamov and Fleury. Picked up Tuch tonight since both of them are playing and once again he produced with a PP goal and an assist..bringing him up to a PPG pace.

Don't want to give up that goalie spot since goalies like Anderson, Talbot, Greiss/Lehner + more are still on the waiver wire so if I pick right that's an extra 5 points for a win and 0.2 for a save. (We get 7 pickups a week)

So basically wondering if Tuch is a better keeper than Guentzel...

Another option would be to trade a defenseman (Piets/Yandle/Barrie/Hedman/Suter) and try and get another starting goalie in return, then keep Guentzel/or Tuch as an open streamer spot.

Thoughts?

[insertnamehere]

You're not gonna get a good answer yet since both players are largely unproven. Guentzel will never sniff the first power play, and Tuch will here and there. Go with your gut, but fwiw, I'm impressed by Tuch so far in his small sample.

- - - Updated - - -

It would help to see your roster. Comes down to whether you need a LW or RW.

[lucafen4]

much better opportunity for Tuch in Vegas then Guentzel in Pitt.

[MZac]

Short term with Crosby out pretzel will get opportunity. Assuming Crosby isn't out long (it's not a concussion, allegedly) then I agree that longer term tuch will get better opportunity. But I'm not dropping pretzel until I hear more about Crosby.

[insertnamehere]

Short term with Crosby out pretzel will get opportunity. Assuming Crosby isn't out long (it's not a concussion, allegedly) then I agree that longer term tuch will get better opportunity. But I'm not dropping pretzel until I hear more about Crosby.

Hahaha awww you fixed the typo, I really appreciated the muddling of the letters to avoid the diagnosis ("it which must not be named")