TJ Oshie vs Jeff Petry

[chuckcouples]

31 team dynasty league where we keep players until we trade them or they become UFAs. Stats we use are goals, assists, hits, blocked shots, +/-, PP TOI/game, PK TOI/game, takeaways. We dress 4 forward lines (positions matter) and 6 dmen each week.

I have received an offer of Jeff Petry for TJ Oshie. I have also received an offer of Justin Schultz and Zach Aston-Reese for TJ Oshie. Should I make either of those moves.

My current lineup is this:

Hall - Carter - Granlund
RNH - Turris - Oshie
Johansson, Marcus - Bellemare - Gourde
Caggiula - Sissons - Rust
Extra: Kuraly, Suomela, Jaskin

Chara - Burns
Lindholm - Larsson
Djoos - Benning
Extras: Heed

Should I accept either of those offers? The question is really Jaskin (or Kuraly or Suomela)+Petry/Schultz OR Djoos(or Heed or Benning)+Oshie.

[chuckcouples]

One GM has offered me Petry for Oshie again while the other is now offering Justin Schultz + Charle Hudon for Oshie. Are either of those moves I should make?

[c_robio]

I would stick with Oshie

[lucafen4]

I don't mind the Petry offer... a 40pt MC Dman for a 55pt forward - sounds very tempting.

I also like Hudon and don't see much difference between him and Oshie within the next 1-2 years - Hudon is going to be solid - hits, sog. a bit snake bitten last year. I'd be tempted more on the second offer to replace Oshie & give more D depth.

I like both offers. You don't get the periphs with the 2nd offer, but you build more depth on your overall roster. Unless a trade comes, Heed's value is toast. That'd be the obvious drop

The one flag on petry is that his value is propped up a bit right now with Weber out. 2nd half - when you need him the most Weber will return and his value will slump. The more I ramble, the more I lean toward deal 2 - Schultz/Hudon

[stevegamer]

I'd take Schultz/Hudon there and run. It's a 31 team league where you're getting a much younger guy who is pretty decent himself in Hudon, and a second useful player back.

[chuckcouples]

I'd take Schultz/Hudon there and run. It's a 31 team league where you're getting a much younger guy who is pretty decent himself in Hudon, and a second useful player back.

Thank you all for your thoughts. What does everyone love so much about Charles Hudon? He's playing less than 9 minutes per game right now with zero PP time as a 24 year old. What are people's expectations for him?

How many points do you think Oshie ends up with?

[bondon]

I honestly think both deals are bad and you're giving up the best player in the deal. I would hold off.

[stevegamer]

Hudon last year had 30 points to Oshie's 47. Hudon had about the same total hits & blocks. Hudon took more shots, and he projects to increase his scoring. You have TOI, which isn't a good category for him, admittedly.

You're also getting Schultz who should move into your lineup.