Rank these goalies - I'll Rep

[LeafsFan1967]

How would you rank these goalies available in my draft, tier wise based on my format (wins/shutouts basically)?

Vasilevskiy, Andersen, Bobrovsky, Rinne, Holtby, Quick, Gibson, Rask, Fleury, Murray, Dubnyk, Jones, Talbot, Price, Bishop, Allen, etc.

[martinc84]

Vasilevskiy
Helleybuck

Andersen
Gibson
Holtby
Rask
Jones
Murray
Quick

Talbot
Price
Allen
Bishop
Rinne
Fleury
Dubnyk

The rest

I know I ranked Rinne low, but he's getting quite old and last year was an abberation. Saros will surprise this year and steal more starts than you think.

That being said, you never know with goalies, look a Price or Hellboy 2016-17 vs 2017-18. I would wait before drafting any and take a flyer on a guy like Luongo, Smith or Elliott.

[LeafsFan1967]

Vasilevskiy
Helleybuck

Andersen
Gibson
Holtby
Rask
Jones
Murray
Quick

Talbot
Price
Allen
Bishop
Rinne
Fleury
Dubnyk

The rest

I know I ranked Rinne low, but he's getting quite old and last year was an abberation. Saros will surprise this year and steal more starts than you think.

That being said, you never know with goalies, look a Price or Hellboy 2016-17 vs 2017-18. I would wait before drafting any and take a flyer on a guy like Luongo, Smith or Elliott.

Thanks, I don't think goalie is really a spot to punt at though, especially since our league is forward heavy for keepers, so there is good quality in the draft at D and goalie. Luongo is in his late 30s, lol. I don't trust any of them, is Vas is there at 11 I think I'd strongly consider taking him. I'd strongly consider Zadina too, as he's got big goal upside and we have a rookie slot, so I can stash him there and just play him if he's up/when things are going well. I think it'd be ballsy to take a rookie in my spot, both where I pick (11) and based on my keeper quality, but I could also wait and grab a good rookie later (ie: 6th round) as I was able to get Boeser there last year, just a matter of picking the right guy.

[teepee1]

Just like the above list, Dubnyk is so underrated. Could be money in this type of redraft.

[LeafsFan1967]

Just like the above list, Dubnyk is so underrated. Could be money in this type of redraft.

Just not sure I have faith in Minny, I guess they're solid in the regular season but other teams have gotten better.

[tweetdrivr]

I agree with the advice above. You don?t need a Vezina winning goalie to win the league. You guys don?t even count rate stats. Up front you need tour team to be elite. In goal a value pick, as stated above, who gives you solid numbers is all you need. There is so much volatility in goaltending anyway. You may hit a home run later in the draft but most likely get those decent numbers you need and use your higher picks for blue chip draft choices. One need look no further than Price last season. I used a first round pick on him and he was terrible. Had I waited and taken say Malkin with that 1st round pick I?d have been in much better shape. If you use a high pick on a G and he has a meltdown you?re screwed. You?re better off being elite in skater cats and have an above average goalie...look at the goalie post?s rankings and pick a tier 1/2 guy when they start running low as the draft goes on.