Worth trading Pacioretty to keep 2 goalies

[BernyBoyD]

League in signature.

I can trade Pacioretty for a 3rd round and Dubnyk

1. Would you go ahead with the trade
2. Is Dubnyk an upgrade over Talbot

I do value Pacioretty quite a bit, specially with Stastny, and I believe I'll be able to grab a fine #2 goalie.

Thank you!

[Hockeytown est. 1926]

Yes Dubnyk is an upgrade over Talbot.

But.
Me personally, I'd rather hold Pax and grab a different goalie.

[hockeyrobot]

I would hang onto Pac. I don't even know if Dubnyk is an upgrade over Talbot at this point.

[Hoopo]

Personally I think Talbot and Dubnyk are pretty close, I wouldn't do this if it means losing Talbot and Pacioretty in favor of Dubnyk. You're also selling low on Pacioretty because he had a rough year and people have short memories.

How come you have Zetterberg listed as D?

[stevegamer]

I'd make that deal. You get pick which can be used to draft a guy reasonably similar to Pacioretty, and you then can deal Dubnyk or Talbot for another pick upgrade. I prefer Dubnyk over Talbot, but which one to keep would depend on the return.

[Dover]

In a 11 team league, Dubnyk has more value than Patch IMO. Patch is more replaceable than a 35 wins G.