That is a very tough pick in those settings...Malkin has the advantage as the top points getter most recently. There's a slight advantage for whoever has the most PPG. Ovie had 17, Stamkos had 15, Malkin had 14. But Malkin also well outpointed Ovie and Stamkos. Malkin still has the injury risk...Stamkos had a good year but weirdly not a lot of goals by his standard.
My gut says Malkin, but it's pretty close.