Rank em... Dubnyk, Quick, Jones, Gibson

[kooter109]

1st league in sight (last years team)

Pre-draft

Currently have Dubnyk have talks about these 3 goalies......

Are they enough of an upgrade to give up top players or picks - which is what is being asked.

Should I just keep Duby,?

Would like to see how others rank these guys.

[DusterDave]

Gibson
Dubnyk/Quick
Jones

Keep what you have.

[SeaDawg]

I'm not very high on Dubnyk, in both the short term and especially in the long-term.

I'd considering making the move, but it depends what exactly you have to give up.

I rank them this way:

Jones
Gibson
Quick
Dubnyk

[kooter109]

I'm not very high on Dubnyk, in both the short term and especially in the long-term.

I'd considering making the move, but it depends what exactly you have to give up.

I rank them this way:

Jones
Gibson
Quick
Dubnyk

Seems to be high pick (1st)....or player a la Nylander, Kessel etc

[mounD]

If you have to give up anything of real value, I would just stand pat with Dubnyk. He's a very solid option on a solid team, and the variation from year to year with goalies is ridiculous. It's generally not worth spending significant assets to "upgrade" your goaltenders, unless it's clear cut. This is not one of those situations.

[pmorrow]

If you have to give up anything of real value, I would just stand pat with Dubnyk. He's a very solid option on a solid team, and the variation from year to year with goalies is ridiculous. It's generally not worth spending significant assets to "upgrade" your goaltenders, unless it's clear cut. This is not one of those situations.

Pretty much agree with this. Dubnyk has been very consistent over the years. The Wild aren't going to dominate this year, but their defence is still pretty good. There's a risk in seeing any of the other 3 as dramatically better than Dubnyk, because we know how these values swing year to year.

Nonetheless...I would rank them like this:

Gibson
Jones
Quick
Dubnyk

very close though.

[Hockeytown Legend]

Keep Dub.
Or make a deal to acquire Jones.
I'd bet he is easier to pry away than say a Gibson or Quick.
SJ is gonna be nasty good and Jones seems like a goalie that could be had for less than Gibson / Quick IMO.

But if nothing pans out - nothing wrong at all with standing pat with Dubnyk.

1st league in sight (last years team)

Pre-draft

Currently have Dubnyk have talks about these 3 goalies......

Are they enough of an upgrade to give up top players or picks - which is what is being asked.

Should I just keep Duby,?

Would like to see how others rank these guys.

[RizzeeDizzee]

If you have to give up anything of real value, I would just stand pat with Dubnyk. He's a very solid option on a solid team, and the variation from year to year with goalies is ridiculous. It's generally not worth spending significant assets to "upgrade" your goaltenders, unless it's clear cut. This is not one of those situations.

This. Dubs has a lock on a starting job and a good team in front of him.

[lucafen4]

There's very little to separate these four from each other. Quick/Gibson are probably the two best goalies, but are on aging teams clinging to Cup dreams. Jones gets a EK boost, but Minn is also expected to be stronger as a team with Suter again healthy. All four are so close, without looking I would also expect their avg draft positions to be within a round of each other - with these four being centre stage in that early/mid draft goalie-run that always takes place. It's not worth giving up very much extra for a perceived bump. Each can flip flop the other in fantasy results statistically every year.