Who to keep

[Ozziemagic]

I can only keep one. Goff or Garoppolo? I?m leaning towards one as I type this, but am interested in hearing others thoughts.

[Bomm Bastic]

Need way more info on league set-up and your overall roster construction to help ya out

[Ozziemagic]

I've been in this league with my Uncles since I was 10. It's a very basic redraft league (we keep it simple so young nieces and nephews can get their feet wet in the fantasy world before moving on to bigger and better leagues). Keep 2 players each year. My first keep comes down to either Devonta Freeman or Christian McCaffrey. We can only keep one from any given position, so my 2nd keep is between Goff and Jimmy G.

Scoring is as follows for the QB position.

Offense	Passing Touchdowns (TD)		3
Offense	Passing Yards (Yds)	Default	Calculate Per Scoring Period, NonCumulative: From 0 to 149, award 0point(s) From 150 to 199, award 2point(s) From 200 to 224, award 4point(s) From 225 to 249, award 6point(s) From 250 to 274, award 8point(s) From 275 to 299, award 10point(s) From 300 to 324, award 12point(s) From 325 to 349, award 14point(s) From 350 to 374, award 16point(s) From 375 to 399, award 18point(s) From 400 to 424, award 20point(s) From 425 to 449, award 22point(s) From 450 to 474, award 24point(s) From 475 to 499, award 26point(s) From 500 to 524, award 28point(s) From 525 to 549, award 30point(s)

[Bomm Bastic]

In PPR CMac over Freeman, but if it's standard scoring don't be afraid to toss him back into the pool. CMac's value drops significantly in standard formats imo because I just don't see many TDs or rushing yards in his future. How many teams are in this league?

In 10-12 one QB leagues I wouldn't be be afraid to throw both QBs back in and opt for keeping another RB or WR. That said, if your not comfortable doing that, I'd opt for the younger Goff who has more NFL playing time over Jimmy G who is mostly hype at this point given his small (see: VERY small) sample size.