Heiskanen or McAvoy?

[PrairieDog]

Thank you very much lady & gentlemen, I got McAvoy

My D corps (dress 4) now looks like this: Karlsson, Carlson, Klingberg, McAvoy, Shattenkirk, Pulock, Orlov (Farm: Niku, Hague, Fox).

[lucafen4]

I would go with McAvoy because:

A. We've seen what he can do at the NHL level, so there's 0% risk
B. He will be the B's #1D in all situations
C. I think Klingberg is a bigger roadblock than Krug

That said, Heiskanen is a blue chip stud. But why not go with the sure thing in McAvoy?
I think they both have 50-55 potential, but I love what I've seen from Cholly.

McAvoy looks pretty blue too for wearing black, gold and white

[als_revenge]

I wonder who JP would have taken in this...

I for one also would have gone McAvoy.

[poolsharks]

I would go with McAvoy because:

A. We've seen what he can do at the NHL level, so there's 0% risk
B. He will be the B's #1D in all situations
C. I think Klingberg is a bigger roadblock than Krug

That said, Heiskanen is a blue chip stud. But why not go with the sure thing in McAvoy?
I think they both have 50-55 potential, but I love what I've seen from Cholly.

The Klingberg roadblock is huge . McAvoy for me !

[PrairieDog]

I wonder who JP would have taken in this...

Merit-based. McAvoy's top lobster.