Tarasenko or Panarin

[pmorrow]

Next three years who do you prefer?

edit - Focussing on points totals, but PPP and SOG important as well.

[Moses]

Next two or three years who do you prefer?

What are we asking them to do?

[pmorrow]

What are we asking them to do?

Mostly looking at points, but SOG and PPP important too.

[FinnishFlash]

For points I prefer Panarin

[LEAFS225]

Panarin for me, both 26 and even though Panarin has scene a change of scenery in Columbus he has improved. Wherever he goes he goes he just has so much skill to not put up points.

[Patysboy]

Tank for me!

[FrozenInferno]

Another vote for Panarin and bonus points for being a left wing

[MZac]

Mostly looking at points, but SOG and PPP important too.

I think panarin will out point him by about 5-10 most years. Tank will out shoot panarin by about ~40-80 and most years they should be pretty close in ppp's. So depending on the weighting but if points are what matter most with no goal weighting then I'd go panarin. Tanks injury could factor in as well but I think he'll still be elite.

[StuntMan12]

I went with Tank. Both should be between 5 or so points between eachother.

[roenick27]

I think panarin will out point him by about 5-10 most years. Tank will out shoot panarin by about ~40-80 and most years they should be pretty close in ppp's. So depending on the weighting but if points are what matter most with no goal weighting then I'd go panarin. Tanks injury could factor in as well but I think he'll still be elite.

This is pretty dead on

[Moses]

I like Tarasenko's stability. He's my pick today. I have no idea where Panarin is going to be next year (or even this year).

[HonkyTonkMan]

Panarin. He proved he is the real deal and has had better producing seasons than Tank points wise

[FantasyKing]

I went with Tank here, it's pretty close though.

[The Comish]

Gun to head (no fence sitting for this guy!), I went with Panarin, but Tarasenko is oh so tempting.

[hockeymanG23]

To close to call so I voted a draw. If forced to pick one I’d lean toward Panarin though since he’s shown this year that he can produce very well without another high end forward on his line.