Results 1 to 13 of 13

Thread: Guentzel or Sam Reinhart?

  1. #1
    knoble's Avatar
    knoble is offline
    Join Date
    Jul 2016
    Posts
    592
    Rep Power
    9

    Dobber Sports Apprentice

    Default Guentzel or Sam Reinhart?

    For first team in signature. I currently have Guentzel. This was a counter proposal to a trade I offered so wasn't looking to move Guentzel but thought I would throw it out there and see what people thought of Reinhart?
    25 man roster, 20 keepers.
    goals and assists are each 1 point each, bonus point for power play points.
    1st teamC: S. Aho, E. Malkin, W. Karllson, B. Nelson
    LW: B. Marchand, A. Ovechkin, J. Zucker, N. Niederreiter, A. Svechnikov,

    RW: D. Perron, J. Kyrou, C. Keller, D. Strome, T. Toffoli, C. Perfetti,
    D: j. Carlson, D. Hamilton, R. Andersson, F. Hronek,J. Spurgeon
    G: , C. Hellybuck, J. Ottinger, A. Vasilevskiy

    2nd team
    C: E. Lindholm, J. Pavelski, JT Miller, R. Johansen, A. Killorn, B. Jenner(IR)

    LW: , B. Marchand, A. Mangiapane, T. Toffoli, J. Gaudreau

    RW: P. Kane, Pasta, D. Perron, T. Wilson, N. Schmaltz, M. Tkackuk
    D: J. Carlson, A. Pietriangelo, C. McAvoy, N. Schmidt, J. Trouba, J. Morrissey
    G: J. Markstrom, C. Hellybuyck, T. Jarry

  2. #2
    Location
    Regina, SK...EH!
    Rep Power
    50

    Dobber Sports Icon

    Default Re: Guentzel or Sam Reinhart?

    I dunno. I'm not big on either really. Gun to my head I'd say Reinhardt..but only because I dont like Guentzs dependancy on Sid..I guess some could be said for Reinhardt and Eichel.

    I keep waiting for SR to break out..maybe this is it?

    Is suspect I will be in the minority as there is some Geuntz love here...sounds creepy like that
    ESPN Roto 10 team
    24 man roster (+3 IR) - Keep 20 - Daily settings
    Start 3C, 3LW, 3RW, 5D, 2G, 1UTIL
    G,A,PTS, +/-, PIM, PPA, PPG, D PTS - W, SV, SV%

    C- Zegras, Suzuki, Carlsson
    RW- Batherson, Foerster, Michkov, Kakko, Toffoli
    LW- BTkachuk, Stutzle(C), Byfield(C), McTavish(C), Benson
    D- Minyukov, Sanderson, LHughes, Clarke, Faber
    G- Wolf, Askarov, Wallstedt
    IR- Norris(C)
    IR- Fantilli(C)
    IR- Quinn(RW)
    Picks in 2024/25 rounds 1,1,1,2
    Picks in 2025/26 rounds 1,1,3,4




  3. #3
    Location
    Ottawa
    Rep Power
    50

    The Great One

    Default Re: Guentzel or Sam Reinhart?

    I like Jake in points only, but Reinhart has a better edge with PPP (top line). How big is that bonus?

  4. #4
    knoble's Avatar
    knoble is offline
    Join Date
    Jul 2016
    Posts
    592
    Rep Power
    9

    Dobber Sports Apprentice

    Default Re: Guentzel or Sam Reinhart?

    Quote Originally Posted by als_revenge View Post
    I like Jake in points only, but Reinhart has a better edge with PPP (top line). How big is that bonus?

    The power play bonus is just an extra point, so 2 points for a power play goal/assist compared to 1 point for even strength goal/assist.
    That can add up a bit over time.
    For reference,
    Guentzel had 48 actual points last year which translated to 64 fantasy points in my league.
    Reinhart had 50 actual points last year which translated to 73 fantasy points.

    Not a huge difference but a difference none the less. The question is, will either seperate themselves from the other going forward?
    1st teamC: S. Aho, E. Malkin, W. Karllson, B. Nelson
    LW: B. Marchand, A. Ovechkin, J. Zucker, N. Niederreiter, A. Svechnikov,

    RW: D. Perron, J. Kyrou, C. Keller, D. Strome, T. Toffoli, C. Perfetti,
    D: j. Carlson, D. Hamilton, R. Andersson, F. Hronek,J. Spurgeon
    G: , C. Hellybuck, J. Ottinger, A. Vasilevskiy

    2nd team
    C: E. Lindholm, J. Pavelski, JT Miller, R. Johansen, A. Killorn, B. Jenner(IR)

    LW: , B. Marchand, A. Mangiapane, T. Toffoli, J. Gaudreau

    RW: P. Kane, Pasta, D. Perron, T. Wilson, N. Schmaltz, M. Tkackuk
    D: J. Carlson, A. Pietriangelo, C. McAvoy, N. Schmidt, J. Trouba, J. Morrissey
    G: J. Markstrom, C. Hellybuyck, T. Jarry

  5. #5
    Location
    Cape Breton
    Rep Power
    21

    Dobber Sports Padawan

    Default Re: Guentzel or Sam Reinhart?

    I like Reinhart for a bit of a breakout here, Buffalo is on the up and are about to add Dahlin to the mix. Plus Reinhart had a strong finish last season and may finally be turning the corner.

    Guentzel is an animal in the playoffs when he's playing with Sid but in the regular season can't seem to find a consistent line.
    10 Team Fantrax Weekly H2H
    19-Man Roster, 8 Keepers, 12 Minors (<150 NHL Games Kept Free)
    Pos: 3xC / 3xLW / 3xRW / 3xD / 3xG / 1xUtil / 3xBench / 5xIR
    Scoring: (G=1) (A=1) (W=2) (SO=1) (SV=0.05)

    2020-21 League Champion 🏆

    Re-tooling Season. Keepers moving forward:

    C: N.MacKinnon, E.Pettersson, T.Zegras
    LW: A.DeBrincat, A.Svechnikov
    RW: W.Nylander
    D: C.Makar, R.Dahlin

    Notable Minors Eligible/Prospects: C.Sillinger, S.Pinto, P.Krebs, F.Lysell, M.Coronato, S.Perunovich, F.Nazar, S.Durzi, S.Skinner

  6. #6
    FantasyKing's Avatar
    FantasyKing is offline
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    1,074
    Rep Power
    18

    Dobber Sports Padawan

    Default Re: Guentzel or Sam Reinhart?

    Reinhart he finished the season strong, like others have said he's due for a breakout season

  7. #7
    Location
    Beaumont, AB
    Rep Power
    50

    Dobber Sports Icon

    Default Re: Guentzel or Sam Reinhart?

    Another vote for Reinhart.

  8. #8
    Location
    Philadelphia area
    Rep Power
    50

    Dobber Sports Grand Master

    Default Re: Guentzel or Sam Reinhart?

    It's pretty close. I prefer Guentzel, but can't fault either choice.
    Want a Signature? Go to Settings, and you'll find Edit Signature down the list on the left.

  9. #9
    Rep Power
    0

    Dobber Sports Rookie

    Default Re: Guentzel or Sam Reinhart?

    Grab Sam Reinhart and run this guy with Eichel and Dahlin is gonna be beast we have only seen the tip of his potential his ability on the ice reminds me a little if Kariya. I think Buffalo is gonna surprise some this year now they have a PP guy on the back end. Good luck with whatever you choose but to me Reinhart>Guentzel
    Strictly points League (Goalies 2 for win extra one for shutout) (22 Keepers)
    Keeper league
    Roster:
    Frowards: Nathan MacKinnon, Aleksander Barkov, Vladimir Tarasenko, Brayden Point, Viktor Arvidsson, Matt Duchene, Mike Hoffman, Nico Hischier, Anthony Mantha, Alex Killorn, Jonathan Drouin, Bo Horvat, Chris Kreider, Richard Panik ,

    Charles Hudon


    Goalies : Brian Elliott,Cory Schneider, Robin Lehner, Malcolm Subban


    Defense : Ryan Ellis, Jaccob Slavin, Dion Phaneuf, Damon Severson, Jan Rutta, Derek Forbort, Shea Theodore, Arron Ekblad, Shayne Gothisbere

  10. #10
    Location
    Vancouver Island
    Rep Power
    40

    Dobber Sports Jedi

    Default Re: Guentzel or Sam Reinhart?

    I'm tempted to say Reinhart here as well... Note - he's also entering his 4th full season - which is often the breakout year. Makes me lean heavier Reinhart's way 60+?
    Follow me on twitter: @doylelb4

  11. #11
    marc1pol2's Avatar
    marc1pol2 is offline
    Join Date
    Sep 2016
    Posts
    460
    Rep Power
    10

    Dobber Sports Blue-Chipper

    Default Re: Guentzel or Sam Reinhart?

    It's close but I think I would gamble with Reinhart and use the Guentzel's last playoff record to get something added to Reinhart in this deal
    League 1: 10 teams Points only (Best 9F, 4D and 1G count for the season and best 8 for the playoff). Drop 4 players before a 4 round draft before season. Mini draft during all star week-end (drop one pick one available).

    F: MacKinnon, Pettersson, Eichel, Barkov, Stone, Ehlers, Necas, Huberdeau, Zacha, Boldy, , Lafreniere, Cozens, Vilardi
    D: Dobson, Ekblad, DeAngelo, Seider, Bouchard, Matheson, Clarke
    G: Vasilievski, Sorokin


    League 2: 14 teams, same setting.

    F: Rantanen, Kyrou, Barkov, Raymond, Perfetti, Jarvis, Lundell, Lafreniere, Byfield, Holtz, Norris, Reichel, Rossi
    D: Dahlin, McAvoy, Addison, Krug, Lundkvist, Clarke
    G: Sorokin, Demko

  12. #12
    Location
    Ontario
    Rep Power
    40

    Administrator

    Default Re: Guentzel or Sam Reinhart?

    Guentzel for me


    Contact me for Frozen Tools bug reports and inquiries
    Follow Frozen Tools on Twitter @FrozenTools
    Follow me on Twitter @DH_EricDaoust

  13. #13
    knoble's Avatar
    knoble is offline
    Join Date
    Jul 2016
    Posts
    592
    Rep Power
    9

    Dobber Sports Apprentice

    Default Re: Guentzel or Sam Reinhart?

    Thanks for the reply's. Seemed like the 2 players were pretty equal, more of less so the deal ended up as:
    My Guentzel and Brandon Montour for his
    Reinhart and 3rd round pick.
    I wasn't keeping montour so I got a pick which actually is now my highest pick in the draft. Last pick in the 3rd round. Lol I had traded my earlier picks for players to help me push for the championship which worked out as I won the league. I have faith in the dobber community to help me find some gems in the later rounds.

    Thanks again for the help in this minor deal.
    1st teamC: S. Aho, E. Malkin, W. Karllson, B. Nelson
    LW: B. Marchand, A. Ovechkin, J. Zucker, N. Niederreiter, A. Svechnikov,

    RW: D. Perron, J. Kyrou, C. Keller, D. Strome, T. Toffoli, C. Perfetti,
    D: j. Carlson, D. Hamilton, R. Andersson, F. Hronek,J. Spurgeon
    G: , C. Hellybuck, J. Ottinger, A. Vasilevskiy

    2nd team
    C: E. Lindholm, J. Pavelski, JT Miller, R. Johansen, A. Killorn, B. Jenner(IR)

    LW: , B. Marchand, A. Mangiapane, T. Toffoli, J. Gaudreau

    RW: P. Kane, Pasta, D. Perron, T. Wilson, N. Schmaltz, M. Tkackuk
    D: J. Carlson, A. Pietriangelo, C. McAvoy, N. Schmidt, J. Trouba, J. Morrissey
    G: J. Markstrom, C. Hellybuyck, T. Jarry

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •