Who to Keep? Raanta or Schneider

[m29King]

Sounds like a stupid question, but seriously debating who to keep here.

Scored categories are Wins, GAA, SV%, Saves & Shutouts. Weekly line ups.

- Raanta sported one of the highest SV% in the league while being on one of the worst teams.
- Arizona carried a hot hand in the 2nd half of the season. i'm thinking Wins tick upwards.

- Schneider has suffered from two years of lackluster performance
- NJ is on the up and up as well, but Kincaid might be in a 1b position?
- Overall has an amazing track record of performance.

I've held Schneider for 4 years, gave me two good years of performance, but now i'm starting to lose faith a little. Who would you take?

[lucafen4]

I'm with you... that and I've been now waiting two years for Arizona to take a jump in the standings. Give me Raanta

[rtstr]

Schneider for me

[Belexus75]

if you can i would wait till after the draft to make this decision. I have a feeling one of Kinklad or Schnider will be moved. If they move Schnider i would stay away from him. If he stays in NJ it means they still have trust in him and there is chance he bounces back. If there is no trade i have no clue what to think. He has been brutal. Raanta will at best be middle of the pack guy.

[stevegamer]

You need to wait until at least after playoffs to make this decision.

[BreadManPanarin]

If I had to choose right now, I go with Raanta.

.922 save% over his 5 year career. .930 save% this year. Kid is legit, and the team is improving. Can you imagine how much it'll help him if they get Dahlin too?

[Seeds of Grapes]

I think the better question is Rantaa or Schneider or Kinkaid?

[m29King]

Unfortunately i have until Monday to decide....

I think kincaid might get 1B status at the top end. That obviously impairs the value of Schneider a significant amount.

[lucafen4]

I like how Arz improved as the year went and Raanta really settled into the #1 role. his numbers on that bad team are really good. They improve in front of him. he'll move into a top 10G discussion

[Axeman33]

Schneider for me. NJ is riding the hot hand right now but Schneider is still the man in NJ going forward.

[tobias]

From an individual skill standpoint, I truly believe that Schneider is a top tier goalie in the league. I'm not worried about Kinkaid, nor am I taking Raanta over him. Schneider, with no hesitations.

[donpaulo]

Schneider had a strained MCL in his right knee so I think that adversely affected his game this season. In fact he called himself out on his overall play.

I think he is clearly the man in Jersey

but Raanta is really playing well right now

I wish I could trust what Barroway is doing with his hockey team. Will OEL even be in a Coyotes uniform by the start of the season ?

[ericdaoust]

I'd go with Schneider. I have faith in him returning to form.

[stefan17]

I vote raanta. In my personal opinion, Schneider is kind of overrated- I`ve owned him a few times in fantasy and he`s done nothing but sink me. I had him for a little over a month this season and he single-handedly sunk my entire season because he was so bad. I jumped at the first opportunity to get rid of him. And yeah, he`s been bad for 2 years. Give me Raanta-he was literally the only reason I had half-decent goaltending this year. I have zero faith in Schneider and I will never draft him again-I`m tired of being burned.