Please tier these prospects

[Tfan5211]

Points only dynasty could you please tier these prospects


a.gaudette
C.Makar
e.tolvanen
t.liljegren
k.kaprizov
m.frost
m.phillips
e.pettersson
L.kunin
j.kyrou
k.kapanen
c.white
c.mittlestadt
k.kostin
v.abramov
t.raddysh

[Cdot588]

Here goes nothing:

tier 1:
Tolvanen
Kaprizov (if he ever plays)
Petersson
Mittlestadt

on the cusp of tier1:
Makar

Tier 2:
Liljegren
Frost
Kyrou
Kostin

Tier 3:
Abramov
Kapanen
White
Gaudette

Tier 4: the rest

[jman]

Here goes nothing:

tier 1:
Tolvanen
Kaprizov (if he ever plays)
Petersson
Mittlestadt

on the cusp of tier1:
Makar

Tier 2:
Liljegren
Frost
Kyrou
Kostin

Tier 3:
Abramov
Kapanen
White
Gaudette

Tier 4: the rest

I like these tiers but would indeed put Makar in the top tier.

[Bra]

I think you're underestimating Gaudette.

otherwise looks good

[finnys_fanatsy]

care to rank Tier 1?

[Bra]

care to rank Tier 1?

Tolvanen. He stands alone.

Tier 2 is crowded with Makar, Middlestadt, Peterssen, Gaudette

[Dennis]

I like CDot's tiers more or less. Mine are

Tier 1:
Kaprizov
Petersson
Mittlestadt
Tolvanen
Makar

Tier 2:
Frost
Kyrou
Liljegren
Kunin

Tier 3:
Kostin
Abramov
Kapanen
White
Gaudette
Raddysh

Tier 4:

Tier 5:
Phillips

[finnys_fanatsy]

Tolvanen. He stands alone.

Tier 2 is crowded with Makar, Middlestadt, Peterssen, Gaudette

Interesting.

I have seen heated debates on Tolvanen vs Pettersson on HFboards

[VincentVega]

Tolvanen does not stand alone. I have Pettersson ahead of him but in the same tier.

[Zorro]

Tolvanen. He stands alone.

Tier 2 is crowded with Makar, Middlestadt, Peterssen, Gaudette

I wouldn't go that far.. I think Tolvanen, Mittlestadt, Pettersson, and Makar deserve to be in the same tier as of right now anyway.. Kyrou isn't no slouch either..

[audiopile]

e.pettersson
e.tolvanen

c.mittlestadt
C.Makar

j.kyrou
k.kapanen
c.white
t.liljegren
k.kostin

v.abramov
L.kunin
k.kaprizov (2-3 years out or he'd be higher)
t.raddysh

a.gaudette
m.frost
m.phillips


Not looking at other answers.

[reggiebarnes]

Mittlestadt is better than tolvanen in my opinion. I?d rank him and Petersson and Makar together. I?d draft tolvanen after those guys

[Cdot588]

Very debatable between Mittlestadt, Petersson & Tolvanen on who the better scorer will be. All lighting it up in different leagues. Makar is tougher to predict simply because of his position. I think he will be very good, but there have been many defenseman I thought would be good & turned into nothing.

[Dennis]

I'm very bullish on Mittelstadt and love watching his highlights but he is by no means lighting up the NCAA's Big-10 conference. He has 30 points in 34 games. I still think he'll be great, he's the type of player who makes everyone around him better and I do not regret drafting him over Petersson, but Petersson is putting up numbers. You can't argue with numbers.

[Cdot588]

I'm very bullish on Mittelstadt and love watching his highlights but he is by no means lighting up the NCAA's Big-10 conference. He has 30 points in 34 games. I still think he'll be great, he's the type of player who makes everyone around him better and I do not regret drafting him over Petersson, but Petersson is putting up numbers. You can't argue with numbers.

No.. not lighting the NCAA up I guess, but he did have the best performance of the bunch at WJ's of the three. It's a very interesting conversation. All of them will be good, but which one will be better?