Price / Allen / Talbot how do you rank em...

[IngeTheHammerStrom]

How do you rank Allen, Talbot and Price when deciding on a keeper next year?

[lucafen4]

Price



keep going down


Talbot


Allen

[tobias]

Price > Talbot > Allen

[pmorrow]

Price


Talbot

Allen

This could all change fast, but when the season is over and people reflect I think this will be the outlook for next year and the few years after that. It wasn't long ago that Price was considered the best goalie in the league and now people are very worried about him not just now but long term. It's team and opportunity dependent and hard to see further than a year or two ahead.

[IngeTheHammerStrom]

Thanks - also worried about Price and his over-all health. Buddy of mine who played goalie at a high level says that his style of play and his injury history are not a good combination and will likely see more injuries as he ages and wears. If he stays in Montreal for a few more years he will be playing behind a rebuild which is not good for a Fantasy Hockey goalie...

[tropheus_guy]

Talbot>Price>Allen

[Right handed shot]

Price



keep going down


Talbot


Allen

Priceless

- - - Updated - - -

Price



keep going down


Talbot


Allen

Priceless - No pun intended...

[stevegamer]

They are all basically having their worst year ever. I'm basically ranking them on how good they've been in the past, because you could throw a child's blanket over their range of performances this year.

1. Price - He's been elite before. He could be elite again. Team is bad, but that could change if they clean house upstairs. Assuming non-cap league.
2. Talbot - He was great on Edmonton last year, this year the team stinks, and he's been bad for the first time ever. He's never had Price's highs, and has less mileage on him. Edmonton more likely to be good next year.
3. Allen - He's been a basically average or slightly better goalie on a good team. Why would we expect him to break out next year?

[Axeman33]

They are all basically having their worst year ever. I'm basically ranking them on how good they've been in the past, because you could throw a child's blanket over their range of performances this year.

1. Price - He's been elite before. He could be elite again. Team is bad, but that could change if they clean house upstairs. Assuming non-cap league.
2. Talbot - He was great on Edmonton last year, this year the team stinks, and he's been bad for the first time ever. He's never had Price's highs, and has less mileage on him. Edmonton more likely to be good next year.
3. Allen - He's been a basically average or slightly better goalie on a good team. Why would we expect him to break out next year?

I'm inline with stevegamer here, both in rankings and comments.