Barzal vs Laine vs Stone

[ScottStevens]

Hi guys, first post but I've been reading this forum for a while and find the analysis done by you guys very useful and hope to contribute as well.

I'm in a points only keeper league and can probably trade for one of these guys. The prices will be different, but I'm in a position where I can pull off a trade I'm comfortable with for whichever one.

I wanna know how you would rank the three players value for the next 3 to 5 seasons.

[hank mooney]

Barzal
Laine

Stone

[als_revenge]

I'd also go Barzal-Laine-Stone. The hard part though, is the reference to "different" prices. Depending on the price, Stone could give more value.

If you have some offers or proposals involving these three - feel free to post them. You might also get feedback on which target makes sense given the relative cost.

Also, welcome the forum. I gave you a rep to get you started...

[Axeman33]

Welcome to the forums.

I'd have Laine first on this list with Stone and Barzal both very closely behind.

[Kofax]

Barzal/Laine followed by Stone.

Barzal and Laine both appear to have a higher ceiling at this point with similar floor to Stone, while also have the benefit of being younger.

Barzal vs Laine will likely come down to preference, but in my opinion, Barzal will have an easier time creating his own offense while Laine will rely a bit more on those around him.

[saucelife90]

Barzal
Laine
Stone